Buttermilk Bakeshop

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Buttermilk Bakeshop

"Custom wedding cakes, birthday cakes, baby shower and bridal shower cakes, cookies, cupcakes, brownies, cake pops, and pies"

Address: 260 5th Ave , Brooklyn 11215, NY, US

Phone: (347) 987-3941

State: NY

City: Brooklyn

Zip Code: 11215

Opening Hours

Wednesday: 11:00-18:00
Thursday: 11:00-18:00
Friday: 11:00-20:00
Saturday: 11:00-20:00
Sunday: 11:00-18:00

Update Info

related searches: Little cupcake bakeshop Brooklyn, Buttermilk Bake Shop menu, Best birthday cakes in Brooklyn, Best Cake Delivery Brooklyn, Custom birthday cakes Brooklyn, Same day Cake delivery in Brooklyn, Ladybird bakery, Bake Shop brooklyn Menu

Similar places near

Whisk & Whiskey 211 meter

Root Hill Cafe 245 meter

Winner On 5th 260 meter

Julien Boulangerie 294 meter

D' Vine Taste 473 meter

Connecticut Muffin 509 meter

The Showroom Bakehouse 510 meter

Velvette Black 549 meter

Cousin John's Cafe & Bakery 558 meter

Miss American Pie 700 meter

Blue Sky Bakery 796 meter No one else makes muffins like this! Full of juicy fruit and they have a crispy crust...

Colson Patisserie 818 meter

Hungry Ghost 866 meter

Jan's Cupcakes 900 meter

Naidre's Cafe & Bakery 1 miles

Mille-Feuille Bakery 1 miles

Little Cupcake Bakeshop 1 miles

Auntie Annes 1 miles

Reviews

We ordered 2 custom cakes and several desserts from Buttermilk for our wedding weekend, and everything was a hit! Our first Vanilla Mousse cake was for a Swedish Midsummer brunch, and not only was it the prettiest cake that many of our guests have ever seen, it was absolutely delicious, even with the surprise chocolate inside!  Our second cake was Pistachio Honey for the actual wedding, and we pretty much heard nonstop, even days later, that it was one of the best wedding cakes people have ever had. One of my friends even said that it was the first time in her entire life she's ever gone back for a second piece of wedding cake!  The ordering process with Buttermilk was smooth, and they were very responsive and communicative with us, which we appreciated. They answered all of our questions in a timely manner, and were professional from beginning to end. We also loved that there were plenty of vegan and gluten-free options for our guests with dietary restrictions. Can't wait to order more!

These folks made my vision for a surprise custom cake for my partner come true! I sent them pictures of what I had in mind, and their team nailed it! They were able to. create an edible photograph sheet on top of a chocolate ganache, along with my desired birthday message. I was skeptical of it matching my vision, but I was wrong for that! It was perfect! Great communication with the team, too! I had a bunch of questions and instructions about delivery, and they answered everything and maintained contact until everything was complete! Also, fair prices!Especially on such short notice 2 days before event. Thank you!!!

I had a delicious cake prepared for my husband’s birthday.   I thought of a cake at  last minute and Buttermilk was able to prepare  the cake in a day and a half. It was delicious and beautiful. I would definitely use them again.Food: 5/5

I ordered a custom designed wedding cake for the cake cutting at my wedding ceremony, a "kitchen cake" to be sliced and served to guests, and some cupcakes for guets with allergens. The cakes were delivered on time and matched the plan we came up with during the design process. Most importantly, the cakes were DELICIOUS!! and our guests couldn't stop raving about them. We are are more than happy with the service and product received.

We had Buttermilk cater our wedding and it was a huge success! Our guests raved about the dessert table; everything was absolutely delicious and beautifully made. Thank you Buttermilk Bakeshop!!!Food: 5/5

We ordered our small, 2-tier wedding cake from Buttermilk Bakeshop and it was the best decision. Our guests could not stop raving about it. From the taste Rocher and Pistachio Honey were beyond delicious to the presentation to the shop’s service and responsiveness, everything exceeded our expectations. We will definitely be ordering more cakes for future celebrations!

I had to update an order to make my custom cake bigger via the chat feature, and it could not have been easier. The cake for my boyfriend’s birthday was beautiful and everyone loved it. The candles were gorgeous. The shop where I picked it up in person was adorable and I will definitely be coming back. Thank you so much!Food: 5/5

Buttermilk created a custom cake and cupcakes for our dinosaur themed birthday party. With only one inspiration photo, the end result was even better than I envisioned. Our guests were very impressed with the design, but even more impressed with how delicious it all was. Thank you!Food: 5/5

We needed a birthday cake for a four year old and Buttermilk came through on short notice after another bakery cancelled. They were patient and helpful and prioritized the order at the last minute and it came out incredible. Will be coming here for all future needsFood: 5/5

We order a small custom wedding cake from Buttermilk Bakeshop and it was absolutely delicious! We got so many compliments as our guests enjoyed it. The cakes exterior and interior were beautiful and exactly as pictured. Delivery was simple and easy. I can't wait for an excuse to order a cake again!Food: 5/5

Comment on this business

Map, Satellite View
Street View

to add Buttermilk Bakeshop map to your website;

<iframe width="450" height="300" src="https://us.a-better-place.com/v.php?seo=buttermilk-bakeshop&id=2001625&yuk=300" frameborder="0"></iframe><p style="font-size:11px;margin-top:5px;"><a href="https://us.a-better-place.com/buttermilk-bakeshop-i2001625.html" target="_blank" title="Buttermilk Bakeshop">Buttermilk Bakeshop</a></p>

Buttermilk Bakeshop

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Buttermilk Bakeshop

Opening Hours

Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

We use cookies