facebooktwitterpinterest
mobil menu

Gelateria Gentile

  1. New York
  2. New York Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt
  3. New York Gelato
  4. New York Desserts

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Gelateria Gentile

Gelateria Gentile
"Opening: October 19th !!"
Address: 75 University Pl , New York 10003, NY, US
State: NY
City: New York
Zip Code: 10003


Update Info

related searches: Gelateria gentile new york price, Gelateria gentile new york menu, Gelateria gentile new york locations, Gelateria gentile new york delivery, gelateria gentile - williamsburg menu, Gentile gelato menu, Gelateria Gentile Nolita, Gelateria Gentile University Place
Similar places near
NAYA - Union Square NAYA - Union Square 38 meter
Amorino Gelato Amorino Gelato 61 meter
Madman Bakery Madman Bakery 118 meter
Serafina Restaurant Wine Bar Serafina Restaurant Wine Bar 142 meter
Patisserie Fouet Patisserie Fouet 208 meter
Max Brenner - New York Max Brenner - New York 222 meter
Lunetta Pizza Lunetta Pizza 227 meter
Cafedelia Cafedelia 230 meter
Popeyes Popeyes 245 meter
Unregular Bakery Unregular Bakery 264 meter The place and staff are lovely. I missed the sign when trying to find it, but there w...
Baked by Melissa Baked by Melissa 289 meter
In a Jar In a Jar 296 meter
Crumb Cookie Crumb Cookie 298 meter
Matto Espresso Matto Espresso 330 meter
Intoxicake NYC Intoxicake NYC 331 meter
South Of The Clouds South Of The Clouds 364 meter
Loring Place Loring Place 365 meter
Village Breakfast Snob Village Breakfast Snob 379 meter
Reviews
The best gelato place I've been in New York City. As good as the best places in Italy, expensive but in line with other high quality places in Manhattan.Food: 5/5
The coffee granita was unfortunately the worst $10 I have ever spent. The product was all frozen to the bottom so the employees ran the vessel under hot water to get the remnants out which resulted in it being half melted and half large chunks of ice. The recipe is also terrible. It is essentially a very bitter black espresso over shaved ice. The worst part is that is a standard serving for a dessert but a massive serving of espresso. The entire cup is probably equivalent to 8 shots of espresso. I shared it with my fiancé and both of our hearts were racing. The shop is very pretty inside and they have a selection of gelatos and pastries.
We decided to indulge in some dessert at Gentile and were pleasantly surprised by the exceptional quality of their gelatos. I couldn't resist trying the frutto di Bosco and salted caramel flavors, and let me assure you, they were truly some of the best ice creams I've ever tasted. The flavors were rich, smooth, and incredibly satisfying. I wholeheartedly recommend giving Gentile a visit to experience these delightful gelatos for yourself. It's definitely worth it.
Small but authentic gelataria in the middle of New York. They rotate some of their flavors every few months, but the core flavors are constant. I got the pistacchio and caffè flavors, both of which were the delicious. The pistacchio was definitely one of the best pistacchio gelatos I've tasted outside of Italy. I also tried the melannurca, which is an apple liquer. They also had granitas and brioche on offer, but I didn't get around to trying those.
The gelatos are pretty solid. Though they can do better with their waffle cone. The place has so many other pastries I would be keen to try. Worth a visit!Food: 3/5
We used to come to this location almost every weekend with our 8 yr old son. The flavors used to be interesting compared to Amorino across the street. However, they don’t rotate their flavors as much as they used to, and when it’s hot out, their gelato that they scoop out of the fridge is almost melting. Their service has gone downhill too. One of the staff did not provide us with proper amount of gelato when I ordered 2 flavors in a small cup. The first flavor was covered flat on the small cup, but the second flavor barely covered the top of the first flavor. I told her the portion of each flavor was not 50/50. It was more 80/20. She just said “that’s how it is”. Horrible answer and service. Mind you we have been coming to this location for at least 2 yrs. Avoid coming here and spend your money elsewhere.
Great refreshing gelato and sorbet 15 flavors at least with 3 vegan, decent portions and prices $7.50 for 3 scoops, friendly staff and lot of pastry, dessert banofee is highly recommended and beverage options. They let you sample two flavors. Strongly recommend. We had 6 flavors in total and our favorite ones in order were the melancura apple sorbet refreshing and delicious, dark chocolate sorbet and the salted caramel . The remaining three of mango, crema antica and sour cherry were also very good. The dessert options are also worth exploring, especially when it's a bit chilly outside.
My favorite gelato spot in town opens up next to one of my favorite pizza place? Who's saying that NYC is dead? This is heaven! Anyways, Gentile is the best and their quality is consistent. That's why it is not a secret anymore and they're expanding. Do yourself a favour and try the Zabaione. Btw, why are you guys carrying croissants but then open at 10:30AM, way to late for breakfast!
Very slick and clean place that has crepes and croissants. They detail all the ingredients and whether they might trigger allergies or affect those with vegan or dairy restrictions. Salted caramel was tasty though the vanilla was relatively bland and could have had more flavor. Good quality but would like to see some more “verve.”
Gelateria Gentile remains my top gelato/ice cream spot in NYC. Tried their seasonal cherry flavor this time, and it was fantastic. Convenient location, perfect for a rest during city walks.Food: 5/5
Comment on this business

Gelateria Gentile map

to add Gelateria Gentile map to your website;



Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

Copyright 2025 | All rights reserved (v2)

Terms Of Service
Privacy Policy
Business Listing Service Agreement
0.0092 Loaded in seconds

We use cookies

We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on our website, to show you personalized content and targeted ads, to analyze our website traffic, and to understand where our visitors are coming from. Privacy Policy