New York New York Pizza

Reviews, get directions and contact details for New York New York Pizza

"Always fresh, always made from scratch - New York New York makes better pizza, pizza subs, burgers, and Italian food. We provide vegetarian options and a quality delivery service!"

Address: 5509 E Fowler Ave , Temple Terrace 33617, FL, US

Phone: (813) 252-9900

State: FL

City: Temple Terrace

Zip Code: 33617

Opening Hours

Monday: 11:00-22:00
Tuesday: 11:00-22:00
Wednesday: 11:00-22:00
Thursday: 11:00-22:00
Friday: 11:00-00:00
Saturday: 11:00-00:00
Sunday: 11:00-22:00

Update Info

related searches: New York New York Pizza near me, New York New York Pizza menu, New york new york pizza temple terrace menu, New York New York Pizza Ybor, New York New York Pizza menu Sheldon road, New York New York Pizza Coupons, New York New York Pizza locations, New York New York Pizza Tampa

Similar places near

Pizza Hut 819 meter

Reviews

Absolutely fantastic every time! I never stop to write a review but this is my go to pizzeria every time I order in Tampa. Very good topping portions and the crust always tastes delicious! I ordered a white pizza with onion spinach and artichoke hearts.  Keep up the good work!

I used to order pizza from this place online for delivery for while. Last two deliveries were awful. It happened during the weekend. I order early in the morning and what I got last two times were old pizzas. All they did was to warm them up and here is your pizza. I know about pizza. I know they were old. I could tell for the texture, flavor and the smell I could tell and felt it was fermented. The cheese was dry and no salsa under it. They lost more that one costumer. NEVER AGAIN!

Great thin crust pizza. Probably the best I've had in the area so far. I wouldn't call it "NY-style" though, as the crust is a bit different. Delicious, but different.  The only thing is that it's a little pricey for a plain cheese pie compared to those with toppings. There's only a $2 difference between a plain and a supreme, for example.  Don't really understand why it's priced the way it is, but hey, who am I to complain? It's totally worth it if you get one of the prechosen gourmet pizzas.

I'm from New York, and this pizza was pretty good, can't lie. Slices are huge and just thin enough. The specialty slice seemed rather mediocre though, they were really skimpy with the toppings and as a result, over priced. I'd stick with the cheese or pepperoni.

Some how the delivery driver can't find my address even thou I have had many deliveries from here before. While talking on the phone with the delivery driver he seems like he wants to do any effort in finding my address. He was using same GPS as I was and try to coach him but both street names he gave me are not in this apartment complex, he kept giving me excuses, I ask for third street name with no answer. His GPS didnt show street names or numbers even thou I am coaching him while looking at mines - google maps. End up cancelling order after several minutes on the phone with him, $10 tip down the drain for him. Thankfully I was going to pay cash. When I call the pizzeria to cancel, I explain what the situation was and just cancel, like they didn't care, this is how businesses loose customers now a days. No more NY NY Pizza for me, $36 ordered down the drain. As I think of it, they probably didnt even make the order amd just pretend to call as the delivery driver and "not find" the address just so I cancel. Unbelievable.

Excellent food!  One of my favorite pizza places in Tampa, that tastes similar to NY.  Sauce is very good- which makes the pizza!

Ordered pizza, chicken tenders, and fries. The pizza was great, but the chicken tenders were in pieces. We ate the pizza and fries instead. The photo provided is exactly what we were given. Why serve customers obvious cut pieces of tenders?? Not okay.

The pizza was only okay and the staff weren't wearing masks, which I honestly find disgusting during this surge of delta variant COVID-19 cases. The price is reasonable, at least, around $12.80 with tax for a 14". But the flavor was quite bland, and the cheese was a bit rubbery. It was also harder than it should be to place and order; the online ordering was not available at the time I ordered, so I had to find their phone number through the photos in Google Maps.

I ordered an xlarge pizza. The girl who took the order didn’t hear me, I guess, and rang up the wrong pizza. They told me they would need to remake it. Fine. They then charged me for the difference in the order. I used to work in hospitality and I remember restaurants would comp things when there was a mistake on their end. So, not only did I have to wait longer than I should have, all the other stuff I ordered was now cold and soggy. There are too many pizza places around here for me to choose from. I just wanted other people to know they should be sure the girl taking the order is actually listening to you, or else you end up paying for it.

I am the trier of all pizza. In tampa you have so many choices. But this place is numero uno! Tastes just like its from NY and it's amazing! Excellent cheese flavor! Delicious savory sauce.

Comment on this business

Map, Satellite View
Street View

to add New York New York Pizza map to your website;

<iframe width="450" height="300" src="https://us.a-better-place.com/v.php?seo=new-york-new-york-pizza&id=1983728&yuk=300" frameborder="0"></iframe><p style="font-size:11px;margin-top:5px;"><a href="https://us.a-better-place.com/new-york-new-york-pizza-i1983728.html" target="_blank" title="New York New York Pizza">New York New York Pizza</a></p>

Reviews, get directions and contact details for New York New York Pizza

Opening Hours

Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

We use cookies