facebooktwitterpinterest
mobil menu

Old Bull Cafe

  1. Pennsylvania

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Old Bull Cafe

Old Bull Cafe

About

Locally owned and operated. We proudly serve Perry's Ice Cream, elk burgers, soups and subs as well as Elk Mt Wines, and Benezette Coffee Co. coffee.

Story

Family owned and operated business established in 2013. We are located in the midst of Elk Country just minutes from the beautiful Elk Country Visitors Center. Our building is the former St. Cecilia's Catholic Church, built in 1897. After closing as a church in 1965, the building served as the Benezette Community House for many years. Now a quaint café, the Old Bull offers free WIFI to our patrons as well as beautiful outdoor seating complete with a fire ring to enjoy on those cool autumn evenings. Elk do frequent our lovely yard as well, so you might just get lucky and see one or two!

Address: 55 Tuttle St, Benezette, PA 15821, USA
Phone: (814) 787-7545
ten.maertsdniw@llubdlo
State: Pennsylvania
Zip Code: 15821


Update Info
Reviews
We arrived at 2pm on a busy Sunday in late September. But I am told, October & November is busier. We had a party of 6, one of which was a 95 year old. When greeted at the front, we were told there were no tables available. A group was just leaving, so we asked can we sit there. Ok but order while standing here, from the only menu because they don't have any other menus. The dishes were cleared but no one ever came to wipe the table. After sitting for 25 minutes, with a staff of 3 at the average age of 16, our waitress, no idea of her name, took our order. Then came the luke warm iced tea and she would find more straws somewhere, that didn't happen. When the grilled cheeses, side salad & Cole slaw came 30 minutes later, we asked for utensils. We were met with a look, like really? Why? The sandwiches were much better than the service. No one asked if we needed anything & had to wait for a check. Never again. If you aren't prepared now, can't imagine when it's busy.
9 years ago (28-09-2017)
Nice atmosphere, but the food left something to be desired and the prices are too high!
9 years ago (29-10-2017)
Arrived on a Sunday afternoon at 2:30. Two of us. Restaurant was not, by any means, crazy busy. A waitress took our drink orders, then food orders pretty promptly (food order included an appetizer). Our orders were sandwiches and fries. Approximately 1 hr passes. In that time, we flagged a different waitress to get us more drinks as we had not recieved our appetizer and the first waitress had not checked in on us again. We get another drink. No appetizer, had not been checked on again, no apology, nothing after one hour...? So another 1/2 an hour passes we flag down the second waitresss (again, WE got HER) attention and ask when our food would be out, or at least the appetizer. She said "let me go check". She came back out with our food and appetizer. Again no mention of how long it had taken or anything. We look at our baskets and each of us had maybe 10 fries at most as our side of fries. We Eat, head to check out. Waiting in line, a gentleman who had just finished using the restroom and went to leave passes the counter, the cashier (our first waitress who we never saw again) says "Have a nice day". The man either didn't hear her, or possibly had the same experience as a lot of us there that day, did not reply to her. So she screams "OKAY! Just ignore me then!" The people working there were unprofessional, goofing off, throwing things at each other. No wonder we had a bad experience. I know we aren't the only ones. We saw a few groups get up and leave and just pay for their drinks as they were having the same experience as us. Hire more staff, or more professional ones. I always have a wonderful time at Benezette. I love going there as many do. This was one of the worst experiences ever. First and last time at the Old Bull Cafe. Save yourselves time, money, and have a better experience: go somewhere else.
9 years ago (07-10-2017)
Rustic and lovely restaurant. Nice employees. The best Reuben sandwich I've ever had! Delicious ice cream for dessert.
9 years ago (18-07-2017)
We ate here yesterday and the service was AWFUL (thank god the food was good)! People that ordered after us receive their food before we did and we were with another family that by the time we finally did get our food they were done eating theirs. And when we asked when our food would be out, they were very rude and said "we're doing the best we can". We would have eaten inside but there was no room so we said we would eat outside and because we ate outside they charged us an automatic 10% gratuity, which I think was ignorant and then to have horrible service because they all acted like we were inconveniencing them. Next time we will just go the Benezette Hotel!
9 years ago (18-09-2017)
Comment on this business

Old Bull Cafe map

to add Old Bull Cafe map to your website;



Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

Copyright 2026 | All rights reserved (v2)

Terms Of Service
Privacy Policy
Business Listing Service Agreement
0.0025 Loaded in seconds

We use cookies

We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on our website, to show you personalized content and targeted ads, to analyze our website traffic, and to understand where our visitors are coming from. Privacy Policy