Pizza by Lucilles

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Pizza by Lucilles

"A Harlem Pizza shop."

Address: 26C Macombs Pl , New York 10039, NY, US

Phone: (646) 370-4270

State: NY

City: New York

Zip Code: 10039

Update Info

related searches: Lucille pizza, Lucille's Harlem, Uncle Tony's Pizza, Uncle Tony's Pizza harlem, Pepo's Pizza, Pizza near me, Bono Pizza, Cafe Lucille

Similar places near

Victorio's Pizza Plus 523 meter

New Millenium Pizza 579 meter

King's Pizza of Harlem 620 meter

Mama Tina's Pizza 711 meter

Koronet Pizza 1 miles

Pick & Eat 1 miles

Pizza Stop 2 miles

Harlem Pizza Co 2 miles

V & T Pizzeria & Restaurant 2 miles

Mediterraneo Pizza 2 miles

Famous Famiglia Pizzeria 2 miles

Koronet Pizza 2 miles

Marlow Bistro 2 miles Beautiful restaurant with real flower decoration on each table and cute cozy vibe. Fo...

Fumo 2 miles

Lexington Pizza Parlour 3 miles

Enzo Bruni Pizza Gourmet 3 miles

Nick's Pizza 3 miles

Third Avenue Ale House 3 miles

Reviews

Literally the best pizza I’ve had. So many options, including frozen to take home! Plus there’s super yummy vegan options, marinara, grandma and veggie! And the quality is just as good as vegan.Food: 5/5

We order a pizza from here at least once a week honestly, sometimes more - excellent quality and pricing, love the variety, something for everyone. I live with a native New Yorker, and they’re notoriously hard to please when it comes to pizza. Lucille’s never fails!Food: 5/5

I had the meatball pizza and garlic knots. The Meatball was really good & moist had a some spice to it, but needed a bit more salt for me. The center of pizza is really thin making it hard to pick it up without toppings sliding off. The pizza pie cost $24 for four slices. It was good but the garlic knots lacked salt and were drowned in olive oil and garlic. I ordered on Uber eats.

I’ve visited here a few times and the verities pizza are all amazing. Alex and Chris are always accommodating. We tried Lucille next door and had a great time with for date night.Recommended dishesMozzarella Sticks, Fried Brussel Sprouts, Pepperoni Pizza, Broc-Rabe Sausage Square Pizza, Pepperoni Pie, Buffalo Chicken Pie, Cannoli 1pc, lg Margherita Pie, Truffle Fries, Shrimp & Grits, Buffalo Cauliflower Salad, Broc-Rabe Sausage Pie, MVP PieRecommendation for vegetariansHighly recommend

One of the best slices I’ve ever had in the city!!!!Food: 5/5

I live in Washington Heights and I randomly came across this place while looking for delivery pizza. Let me tell you, I am OBSESSED with the square pepperoni supreme pizza! OBSESSED!!!! I order all the time! I’m sure the store knows my name and address by heart now!  It is absolutely fantastic! Dare I say the best square slice in New York?? People always say go to Prince Street Pizza, but in my opinion, Pizza by Lucille has them beat HANDS DOWN! I can’t get enough of it!

$3 slice with a thin chewy crust with a crispy edge...  But a little too much crust edge uncovered. Crust has good flavor. Overall, good coverage of cheese and sauce. Curious as to what type of cheese they use;  has a strange texture. Not really Italian flavored, but a good flavor nonetheless. I'll rate this one at 84.

$80 bill buttttttt….. delish! Quick delivery! Typical fold in half style! Can’t go wrong ordering here if you can’t decide where to order from! Be prepared to spend $$$$

Overall, Lucille's is a solid pizza place ESPECIALLY if you live in the upper part of Harlem.  The only reason I've decided to give them 4 stars instead of 5 is that I feel like the pizza is way too oily. The few times I've ordered it, no matter how well done the pizza appeared to be, the bottom of the pizza was always really oily. Even upon reheating in the oven it was difficult to crisp the bottom of the slice.  Regardless, Lucille's makes a tasty pizza that I CLEARLY ordered several times so the oil isn't too much of a deal breaker.

I frequent this place often, I usually buy 4 slices of pizza two for me and two for my daughter. But tonight I said let me try a pie, I normally don’t buy a Large pie because it’s too much for me and my daughter. But I was told about a smaller pie which had six slices so I said I’ll try that… What I got was the equivalent of two slices shaped as a whole pie for 17.42. When I saw the pie my first instinct was not to buy it but since they made it fresh and I waited ten minutes with a hungry child at home i reluctantly brought it, but let him know I was extremely disappointed. When I got home and told my daughter I also realized this is the same size box I receive when I buy my usual two slices. No way should 17 dollars worth of pizza be able to fit in the same box as 6 dollars worth of pizza.I was so disappointed I didn’t know what to do but call them and complain which didn’t do anything so I decided to write this review. Needless to say my daughter ate all six slices which also confirmed to me that I just aid 17.42 for two slices of pizza. No qualms about the quality the pizza was amazing as usual but now I have to find something to eat for myself. DO NOT EVER BUY A SMALL PIE!!! Just buy four individual slices or 6 you’ll come out better. Very disappointed I just wish he would have let me know the size before hand as I asked about four slices and figured I would get the two extra slices and save a dollar or two I feel like I was ripped off, hence the long review and lack of punctuation. They need to either lower the price of the small pie or take it off the menu all together it’s a complete rip off!!! Yours Truly A disappointed and hungry customer!

Comment on this business

Map, Satellite View
Street View

to add Pizza by Lucilles map to your website;

<iframe width="450" height="300" src="https://us.a-better-place.com/v.php?seo=pizza-by-lucilles&id=1878833&yuk=300" frameborder="0"></iframe><p style="font-size:11px;margin-top:5px;"><a href="https://us.a-better-place.com/pizza-by-lucilles-i1878833.html" target="_blank" title="Pizza by Lucilles">Pizza by Lucilles</a></p>

Pizza by Lucilles

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Pizza by Lucilles

Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

We use cookies