facebooktwitterpinterest
mobil menu

Rustica Trattoria - Pizzeria

  1. New York
  2. New York Pi̇zza

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Rustica Trattoria - Pizzeria

Address: 467 Lexington Ave , New York 10017, NY, US
Phone: (212) 953-5167
State: NY
City: New York
Zip Code: 10017


Update Info

related searches: Rustica trattoria pizzeria new york reviews, Rustica trattoria pizzeria new york menu, Rustica trattoria pizzeria new york delivery, Rustica trattoria pizzeria new york closed, Rustica Trattoria Manville, NJ, La Rustica Pizza, Pizza Rustica NYC, Marinara pizza
Similar places near
99 Cent Fresh Pizza 99 Cent Fresh Pizza 13 meter
Roberta's Pizza Roberta's Pizza 169 meter
Slice Pizza Slice Pizza 199 meter
Little Italy-Pizza Mercato Little Italy-Pizza Mercato 218 meter
Uncle Paul's Pizza Uncle Paul's Pizza 244 meter
Abaita Abaita 283 meter
La Bellezza La Bellezza 294 meter
Prova Pizzabar Prova Pizzabar 312 meter
Picciotto NYC Picciotto NYC 367 meter
Milk 'N Honey NYC Milk 'N Honey NYC 377 meter
Roberta's Pizza Roberta's Pizza 383 meter
La Trattoria La Trattoria 386 meter
Patsy's Pizzeria Patsy's Pizzeria 413 meter
La Vera Pizzeria & Restaurant La Vera Pizzeria & Restaurant 456 meter
Xeno’s Pizza Xeno’s Pizza 527 meter
La Pizza Italia La Pizza Italia 532 meter
Bravo Pizza Bravo Pizza 545 meter
Pizza Art Pizza Art 605 meter
Reviews
Definitely my favorite pizza joint in the UES. The crust is immaculate! It is crispy with a ton of cornmeal on the bottom, something which I love. Pizzas are average in terms of price with a cheese slice at 3$. Definitely recommend if you want good pizza on the go
OMG their pizza hits the spot. Love the Margherita. Just tastes like high quality ingredients. I never tasted cheese and sweet tomatoes of that high quality from a regular mom and pop pizza spot. Plus the portion of cheese has some bite to it which I love, as most Margheritas just have a thin layer of cheese. Nice crunchy crust too despite the saucy toppings. Really satisfying.
Gross. Ordered a meatball sub. They sliced up some slimy meatballs, slopped it beyond recognition with jar sauce, and melted some plastic cheese. Just make yourself an omelette and go to bed. I chucked it out. So grosssFood: 1/5
The slices were weird. The bottom was crispy and kind of crumbly. It oozed out oil. The cheese and sauce tasted very unique. It was cheesy!Food: 2/5
Their pizza is GROSS! I ordered from seamless and it arrived cold, the dough was NASTY and the flavors non existent.Food: 1/5
DON’T GO HERE I ordered from here a few times. It was very okay pizza until this last order. I ordered from here last night. Got a pizza which I’ve ordered several times and an Italian sub. The meat quality in the sub was disgusting - it tasted like cheap bologna. Not to mention the bread was completely soggy the moment it arrived. It was almost as if the sandwich had been sitting pre-made for hours. Secondly, and arguably most importantly, the pizza what they’re known for was made incorrectly wrong ingredients according to their own menu and SOGGY. When I picked up a slice, all of the toppings came sliding off the soggy crust. I called to get a refund or maybe a new remade order and LaRustica refused to make it right. So I was left with a check of $40 and food that we threw away because it was awful.
Delicious pizza!! Came by when needed something to fill the stomach and stumbled upon this place. The staff were incredibly friendly, and the pizza oh boy it was delicious and fresh, I ended up getting a second slice. Thank you!
Long time neighbor, first-time customer & I feel I should apologize for not trying LaRustica sooner! Delicious margarita pizza was delivered in under 20 minutes!! I ordered at 7:38, the estimated delivery time was 8:12, and they were knocking on my door at 7:54! The crust is thin & crispy, the flavor is spot on for me, and the fresh moz & basil was divine! Love that they add garlic! Will order again! Almost makes me glad that Gotham has gone downhill otherwise I would never have discovered LaRustica! Vegetarian options: They have all veggie options on their menu and I guess I did order a meatless pie but it was unintentionally vegetarian; it was delicious so I am sure their veggie pie would be as well.
Holy moly, SO good!! We got a cheese pizza delivered and it was fast and probably the BEST pizza I have ever had!!! Can't wait to visit NYC again and try ALL the things on the menu!!! Bravo!Food: 5/5
Ordered late night ! It literally got here in under 45 minutes - the pizza it was hot and crispy and cheesy absolutely the best crust I've ever had on pizza ! If I could give it a ten I wouldFood: 5/5
Comment on this business

Rustica Trattoria - Pizzeria map

to add Rustica Trattoria - Pizzeria map to your website;



Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

Copyright 2025 | All rights reserved (v2)

Terms Of Service
Privacy Policy
Business Listing Service Agreement
0.0053 Loaded in seconds

We use cookies

We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on our website, to show you personalized content and targeted ads, to analyze our website traffic, and to understand where our visitors are coming from. Privacy Policy