facebooktwitterpinterest
mobil menu

San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina

  1. New York
  2. New York Pi̇zza
  3. New York Itali̇an
  4. New York Wi̇ne Bars

Reviews, get directions and contact details for San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina

San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina
"Order your favorite pizza, pasta, salad, wings and more with San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina located at 1559 2nd Ave in New York, NY."
Address: 1559 2nd Ave , New York 10028, NY, US
Phone: (212) 861-2434
State: NY
City: New York
Zip Code: 10028


Opening Hours

Monday: 16:00-22:00
Tuesday: 16:00-22:00
Wednesday: 16:00-22:00
Thursday: 16:00-22:00
Friday: 12:00-23:00
Saturday: 12:00-23:00
Sunday: 12:00-22:00

Update Info

related searches: San matteo pizzeria e cucina new york reviews, San matteo pizzeria e cucina new york menu, San matteo pizzeria e cucina new york delivery, San Matteo NYC menu, San Matteo pizza Espresso Bar, San Matteo Upper East Side, San Matteo 2nd Ave, San Matteo reservation
Similar places near
Aunt Jake's Aunt Jake's 13 meter
Sistina Sistina 14 meter
La Pecora Bianca La Pecora Bianca 54 meter
La Mia Pizza La Mia Pizza 97 meter
Bonjour Crepes & Wine Bonjour Crepes & Wine 109 meter
Campagna Ristorante Campagna Ristorante 153 meter
Emmy Squared Pizza - Upper East Side Emmy Squared Pizza - Upper East Side 204 meter
Tiramisu Tiramisu 220 meter
Parma Nuova Parma Nuova 236 meter
Due Due 236 meter
Pil Pil Pil Pil 238 meter
Antonucci Cafe Antonucci Cafe 238 meter
Williamsburg Pizza Williamsburg Pizza 242 meter
Luke's Bar and Grill Luke's Bar and Grill 246 meter
Lusardi's Lusardi's 267 meter
Ed's Elbow Room Ed's Elbow Room 268 meter
Madame Bonté Madame Bonté 268 meter
Elio's Elio's 275 meter
Reviews
Our server had a great attitude. I would have loved a pot of tea to keep me warm, unfortunately they don't have tea, and the cups of coffee are European sized and not my taste. The atmosphere, attitudes and aromas made great strides in making me feel comfortable on a chilly New York evening. I love how everything is made from scratch on premises - the raw meat and pizza dough makers and there for all to admire when you don't consider the cals or heart attacks lol.
Good pizza if you want the napoli experience without flying to Italy. I went to naples last month and let me tell you this is authentic as it gets. Some one used to ny pizza might be turned off by the floppiness of the pizza but in order to get that bread to cheese and sauce ratio it's unfortunately inevitable since there isn't enough bread at the center to make it structurally sound. Try the sardine pizza it's not too strong or oily.
The dough is very good. Thin and tasty like a real Italian pizza. Unfortunately the quality of ingredients, or at least cheese, is not there at all. There was supposed to be Mozzarella di buffala on the pizza, but it's clearly not there. The basil was also kind of absent.Food: 3/5
Ordered a pizza which arrived totally messed up. Called the restaurant about it and they wouldn’t send a new pizza over, kept referring me to Uber eats. We’ve ordered San Matteo’s at least 20 times and never had a problem. Really really disappointing experience this time… Pretty surprising they wouldn’t replace the order for a loyal customer. The hostess originally said she would send a new pizza but then called 20 mins later to say the manager wouldn’t allow it… very disappointed.
Our table of 6 was very happy with everything we tried. Service and food are outstanding. Ambiance is casual, fun, dynamic and bright. We over-ordered by 30-50% but wanted to try so many dishes. The standout was the panuozzo di bartolome - not to be missed!!! Loved the cacio e pepe pizza and the special pizza fig, prosciutto and the broccoli rabe. Then we ordered pastas gnocchi, rigatoni allá Bolognese, the special with shaved truffles and both the eggplant and the chicken parmigiana. Top this off with some great cocktails and a bottle of wine, a tiramisu and a lemon almond cake and we rolled out of there with full bellies and a few doggie bags! Highly recommend.
I ordered a marinara pizza. Anywhere else in the world, a marinara pizza has sauce only. This one came with anchovies, olives and capers. I called to explain that the pizza had all of this unidentifiable items on top and the man was unrelenting saying this is a special recipe and I should have known. Never again. Crust was burnt! Worse pizza and so mushy!
Ordered online and it came 1.5 hours late, cold and soggy, folded on itself, and a complete mess. in between I called asking for assistance and they either did not pick up or were not helpful on my order status. Only reason I gave 2 stars is because my prior to experiences were not as horrible. I know this is not the norm but still, should never happen.
Simply amazing amazing food. The pizzas are the best high quality “fancy style” pizzas in NYC! The crust is nice and crunchy and has little burned tips just amazing. They have a wide selection of delicious apps and drink/wine selections. The staff are friendly attentive and super amazing. I ended up ordering delivery a week later! Highly recommended.
The « Tartufata » was the best pizza I’ve had in a long time. Perfect balance between the ingredients, not too salty, the ham was very thin and the truffle tasty. Would recommend!Food: 5/5
I strolled into San Matteo with my wife on a fall Sunday afternoon and it was the best experience I’ve had here in NYC. We were warmly greeted by the staff and decided to sit at the bar to watch a bit of NFL red zone. Our waiter’s name was Andres and he was PHENOMENAL. He was genuine and kind and knew the whole menu front to back. The espresso was poppin and the food was incredible. It is crazy out of the days I’ve spent here in NYC that the short time I spent at San Matteo was probably my favorite experience. Andres you are the man and keep serving with that smile you have that shines so bright.
Comment on this business

San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina map

to add San Matteo Pizzeria e Cucina map to your website;



Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

Copyright 2025 | All rights reserved (v2)

Terms Of Service
Privacy Policy
Business Listing Service Agreement
0.0255 Loaded in seconds

We use cookies

We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on our website, to show you personalized content and targeted ads, to analyze our website traffic, and to understand where our visitors are coming from. Privacy Policy