Scotch N Sirloin

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Scotch N Sirloin

"The Scotch 'N' Sirloin hasn't been around for 45 years without being the best dining experience in Buffalo and WNY. We have always been run by local people who grew up in this area. We have always considered the Scotch as our second family and invite you to dine with us anytime. Call or visit us today."

Address: 3999 Maple Rd , Amherst 14226, NY, US

Phone: (716) 837-4900

State: NY

City: Amherst

Zip Code: 14226

Opening Hours

Monday: 16:30-20:30
Tuesday: 16:30-20:30
Wednesday: 16:30-20:30
Thursday: 16:30-20:30
Friday: 16:30-20:30
Saturday: 16:30-20:30
Sunday: 16:30-20:00

Update Info

related searches: Scotch n sirloin amherst prices, Scotch n sirloin amherst menu, Scotch n sirloin amherst dress code, Scotch n sirloin amherst reviews, Scotch n sirloin amherst menu prices, Scotch 'N Sirloin menu, Scotch and Sirloin locations, Scotch 'N Sirloin closing

Similar places near

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant 99 meter

Red Lobster 110 meter

IHOP 158 meter

The Burger Den 227 meter

Denny's 237 meter

Red Robin Gourmet Burgers and Brews 310 meter

Brick House Tavern + Tap 339 meter

TGI Fridays 586 meter

Tully's Good Times - Amherst 656 meter

Outback Steakhouse 739 meter

Chili's 844 meter

CoreLife Eatery 1 miles

Panera Bread 1 miles

Applebee's Grill + Bar 1 miles

Miss Saigon 322 miles

Crazy Noodles 322 miles

Reviews

Dinner was good. I would have given 5 stars but my porkchops were a little under cooked near the bone. My friend said his steak was delicious and cooked perfect. Next time I'll order steak at the steakhouse!!

Have ALWAYS loved this place!! So sad, yet another establishment, is closing. They will be missed terribly  Food, service and management was top notch as always! Thank you Scotch for making my last trip there and my Mother's Day spectacular !Food: 5/5

We had yet another AMAZING dinner at Scotch and Sirloin!!  Service as well as flavor and doneness!!  I've ALWAYS been told to never order seafood at a steak house. I have NEVER been disappointed!!  Hubby always steak...me always seafood. US... always escargot!! ALWAYS amazing!!

Service was excellent, soup de jour soup of the day chicken noodle was decadent, and the ambiance is good. Noise level is a 4.  hence the 2 stars. The bread they serve is dry and not warm, the Caesar salad is served with a brown Caesar dressing which doesn't taste right, and for $37 that NY strip should've been out of this world. Unfortunately, it was tough to chew and had gristle in almost every bite and tasted churned. The curried rice was not good and the snap peas well I'm not a fan. Overall this steakhouse has Ruth Chris prices and IHOP quality. I was not impressed.

Most of us ordered prime rib & it was tough as nails... 2 of us in our party got their prime rib bone in, which I can never remember seeing.  Seems like they are closing because they can't get good beef & staff, as they used to be open late for bar folk - thimk thry close at 8pm now.  Week to go before they close forever Food: 2/5

Throwback atmosphere, like walking in to a time warp.  Was really impressed with the food tho, I loved the peppercorn crusted filet.Food: 4/5

A little bit more on the expensive side but you get what you pay for. Amazing food and great service. I hsd the Ribeye steak recently and it was cooked to perfection. Melted in my mouth seasoned expertly my complements to the Chef and being a Chef myself I don't give compliments like that lightly.

Our Dinner Club recently visited here! Started off with the French Onion Soup!  Love that melted cheese!! I then had the Teriyaki Steak and my wife had the Shrimp Scampi.  Both dishes were amazing...Also worth noting that we enjoyed the all you can eat salad bar prior to the dinner plates.

We had a Shrimp Scampi, 10oz prime rib, stuffed peppers. In pictured Not pictured Broccoli cheddar soup, and mushrooms. Everything was very good.

I don't know if the food was rushed because we came around 7 and they close at 8 but I was majorly disappointed. One the waitress couldn't even remember the specials she was decent but never once smiled!!! She didn't even offer steak sauce once the food came had to get another waiter to do it. Now as for the food it was bland no seasoning at all. The steak good sear but bland so was the vegetables and salmon. The only decent thing was the bread and stuffed banana peppers. For $135 I could not believe it I'm willing to pay for anything worth it but this experience was horrible. Even the fried shrimp batter was bland. I still left a decent tip because that's just who I am.

Comment on this business

Map, Satellite View
Street View

to add Scotch N Sirloin map to your website;

<iframe width="450" height="300" src="https://us.a-better-place.com/v.php?seo=scotch-n-sirloin&id=2017097&yuk=300" frameborder="0"></iframe><p style="font-size:11px;margin-top:5px;"><a href="https://us.a-better-place.com/scotch-n-sirloin-i2017097.html" target="_blank" title="Scotch N Sirloin">Scotch N Sirloin</a></p>

Scotch N Sirloin

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Scotch N Sirloin

Opening Hours

Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

We use cookies