Secret Sandwich Society

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Secret Sandwich Society

Address: 103 Keller Avenue, Keller Ave, Fayetteville, WV 25840, USA

Phone: (304) 574-4777

Website

State: West Virginia

City: Fayetteville

Zip Code: 25840

Opening Hours

Monday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Tuesday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Thursday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM
Sunday: 11:00 AM – 9:00 PM

Update Info

Similar places near

Bojangles' Famous Chicken 'n Biscuits 2 miles We arrived minutes after they closed due to the weather on a Saturday night yet the m...

The Custard Stand 4 miles This is a little out of the way for me but it is definitely worth it. Best custard I ...

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant 17 miles This Olive garden has definitely improved since it first opened. Every time I go it's...

Panera Bread 18 miles A very cozy place. It has a fireplace!! Very nice dining area. The creamy broccoli so...

Taco Bell 18 miles Best tacos we’ve had in a LONG time. Fresh and soo good! Every Taco Bell we’ve been t...

Macado's 18 miles I have taken my daughters here twice. I have been here multiple times without them. ...

Roma Pizza & Grill 20 miles I ordered from Roma Pizza yesterday for the first time and was very pleased. I saw th...

Taco Bell 20 miles Closest fast food too my house, so I'm a frequent customer. Food is always good, and ...

Pizza Hut 21 miles Food was okay.. as good as expected for Pizza Hut I guess. The store it's self could ...

Taco Bell 23 miles Hiw can you go wrong with tacos and burritos. Chaep and quick. Live this place.

Taco Bell 31 miles Pretty good tacos, prices were a bit higher than I like but the employees were very f...

Jimmy John's 35 miles Left the cookie off my order but charged me for it, I didn't know until I got back to...

Chili's Grill & Bar 35 miles No drink refills, server didn't check back to see how everything was going for us. Ha...

Taco Bell 35 miles Had a great experience here. My daughter only likes soft tacos with meat, cheese, an...

Panera Bread 36 miles The staff is friendly and is very patient when you're unsure of what you want to orde...

Shoney's 36 miles Service was lacking, server would ask do you want a refill disappear then come back 1...

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant 38 miles specialty meals (chicken picata, scampi, etc) are tastey and well done. Does seem ...

Firehouse Subs 38 miles Place is very neat, clean and staff is very respectful and patient. Food is very well...

Reviews

I'd been wanting to try SSS for the longest time, and it did not disappoint. When we first arrived, we were told we'd have about a 30 to 40 minute wait. This was on a Saturday night; so, no surprises there! The wait was quite enjoyable because we headed upstairs to a small little bar called The Grove while awaiting a text from the hostess to let us know that table was ready. 

It was a treat to watch a live band called Long Point String Band while we waited. They were actually quite good, and named after a trail that we'd just hiked Long Point Trail. Soon we were called to our table. I was almost sad to go!

But, the sadness soon faded when the Fillmore arrived, which is a delicious eggplant sandwich. Comes with chips, but I upgraded for $1 to the fries. And the complimentary and very crunchy dill pickle was a nice treat. The food was awesome, and the vibe was unique. What else what would you expect from a place that names it sandwiches for Presidents and its salads after First Ladies? I highly recommend this place for date night!

 7 years ago (05-03-2018)

Very Unique & Chill Spot! They consistently serve delicious food and tasty coffee. The outside dining area is heated during the colder seasons and it has a really nice atmosphere. You can also enjoy the live bands upstairs. Great for families, couples, and semi-large groups!

 7 years ago (13-02-2018)

Truly outstanding sandwiches - all named for presents - in a cool, hip setting. I'd never been here before but as we wandered through the area the other day, we stumbled on this place. Boy am I glad we did - the sandwiches are incredible. They also have a wide variety of beers, but it may be a bit too wide? To me, some of the flavors were just ... odd. But I like a more traditional beer. If you like other flavors in yours, this place is worth a visit. Also, I have to say the desserts look AMAZING, but I didn't have one so can't say for sure.

 7 years ago (09-01-2018)

Everything here is so good! We split the Quincy, Truman, and Adams, and we ordered the loaded pimento fries as a starter. The Quincy was the best, and the Adams was a very close second. The Truman was very good, but the other sandwiches were so good that it could only come in third.

 7 years ago (13-03-2018)

Different combinations of Sandwiches. The two sandwiches that I tried were very good. The homemade ketchup was very good. The pickle on the other hand had way too much garlic. I ended up tasting it all day. Two sandwiches, one with chips and one with fries and two can drinks was 27 without tip. Trendy hipster type place. I would go back.

 7 years ago (04-01-2018)

Comment on this business

Map, Satellite View
Street View

to add Secret Sandwich Society map to your website;

<iframe width="450" height="300" src="https://us.a-better-place.com/v.php?seo=secret-sandwich-society&id=65549&yuk=300" frameborder="0"></iframe><p style="font-size:11px;margin-top:5px;"><a href="https://us.a-better-place.com/secret-sandwich-society-i65549.html" target="_blank" title="Secret Sandwich Society">Secret Sandwich Society</a></p>

Secret Sandwich Society

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Secret Sandwich Society

Opening Hours

Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

We use cookies