facebooktwitterpinterest
mobil menu

Attilio's Pizzeria and Restaurant

  1. New Jersey
  2. New Jersey Meal Delivery
  3. New Jersey Meal Takeaway
  4. Toms River Meal Takeaway

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Attilio's Pizzeria and Restaurant

About

Toms Rivers oldest pizzeria. Opened and operated by the same family since 1973.

Address: 941 NJ-166, Toms River, NJ 08753, USA
Phone: (732) 240-1331
moc.liamg@liamesoilitta
State: New Jersey
Zip Code: 08753


Update Info
Similar places near
Buffalo Wild Wings Buffalo Wild Wings 167 meter Ordered a split bucket of wings for take out... wings were great asked for well done....
Panera Bread Panera Bread 316 meter Love this place... I pop in just for green tea. Police fire ems get roughly 50% off ...
Office Office 529 meter So I found The Office when I googled local restaurants in Toms River. We were stayin...
Wolfie's Wolfie's 1 miles The only way to get the proper amount of meat on your sandwich here is to order extra...
The Real Pizza LLC The Real Pizza LLC 1 miles Best pizza in the area and best employees. You always feel welcome and you can see h...
Margaritas Margaritas 1 miles Went back for a second time, this is an updated review. Service was excellent, meals...
Golden Dragon Kitchen Golden Dragon Kitchen 1 miles Very good. Ordered Shrimp with lobster sauce& house special fryed rice. Fried rice w...
Blue Fountain Restaurant Blue Fountain Restaurant 2 miles Good food, good prices, good service... Always have lunch for tomorrow...
Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Olive Garden Italian Restaurant 2 miles Long wait for a table, but that's expected anywhere you go around 6ish on a Saturday....
Chili's Grill & Bar Chili's Grill & Bar 2 miles Waitress was attentive when we arrived. We ordered an appetizer which finally arrived...
Lisa Pizza and Restaurant Lisa Pizza and Restaurant 2 miles I always enjoyed coming to Lisa's, I live up north Jersey and when I would visit my m...
Taco Bell Taco Bell 2 miles Despite it being 130am, the drive through rep. was funny and made sure the order was ...
Taco Bell Taco Bell 2 miles Yo quiero Taco Bell! I miss that chihuahua, but he (actually SHE - her name was Gidge...
Domino's Pizza Domino's Pizza 3 miles This Dominos always delivers hot and quick and although we live in NJ...famous for it...
Five Guys Five Guys 3 miles Guaranteed same great burger every time. My favorite topping is GRILLED ONIONS. When ...
Dragon Chinese Kitchen Dragon Chinese Kitchen 3 miles They’re extremely rude I tried to order my freakin food over the phone and said an or...
Driftwood Deli & Sub Shop Driftwood Deli & Sub Shop 3 miles My first time here, I was not enamored, yet I persevered and fell in love with the pl...
Linda's Pizza Linda's Pizza 3 miles Would not recommend this place to my worst enemy!! Catering Nightmare!! Called to ord...
Reviews
In my neverending quest for the best cheesesteak in Toms River, it's only fitting that on the verge of moving an hour and a half away, I finally got around to Attilio's. Located in a really crappy strip mall you can't make a left turn into, currently moated off by some vague road construction project, it doesn't have a lot of curb appeal. But the food inside is definitely above average. The bread is excellent, and the sandwiches are slightly toasted to add a satisfying crunch. Made with white American mixed into the steak, which seems to be of a higher quality than several other nearby spots, I really can't find much to complain about. And yet... There is one thing. Any topping you add to the sandwich is an additional 50¢. Not really that big a deal, but on my most recent trip, I ordered one with lettuce, tomato, onions, and hot peppers. Half a dollar each bought a ton of lettuce and hot peppers, but only two slices of tomato and three or four measly rings of raw onion. So, the blanket pricing approach to toppings wasn't exactly equitable. As an aside, I also asked for mayo, which they do not charge for, and it was applied somewhat sparingly, as though it were made from Iranian Beluga caviar and gold. All of this can be fixed. "Please go heavy on the onions and mayo, and light on the peppers." Et, voila. An excellent cheesesteak, which by the way, is perfectly good when served plain, without adjustment or special requests. Sadly, I won't have too many more of these, because there are only so many cheesesteaks I can justify eating in the span of three weeks, but the one or two I will should definitely be from here. Oh, also - they have excellent soups, and a pretty decent Cobb salad. I haven't tried the pizza, but being the oldest pizza place in town, I have to assume they do that right as well.
9 years ago (29-09-2017)
Always good food and service.
9 years ago (31-10-2017)
My friends and i went here for the first time since they closed from the fire. Staff was very accommodating, let us take back an extra order that we had made by mistake and is a BYOB place. The pizza was very good and was cooked perfectly, unlike the other pizza place around that tends to overcook the pizza from time to time. Lived in the area for 22 years and highly recommend Atilios.
9 years ago (31-05-2017)
I love you guys best pizza I have ever had. I always order from this amazing pizzeria. Staff is very friendly and I have been a customer for 17 years even before I had my kids for any occasion I would order from Atilois. My kids love love this pizzeria
10 years ago (28-01-2017)
The best pizza in town! Great cannolias!
9 years ago (03-06-2017)
Comment on this business

Attilio's Pizzeria and Restaurant map

to add Attilio's Pizzeria and Restaurant map to your website;



Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

Copyright 2025 | All rights reserved (v2)

Terms Of Service
Privacy Policy
Business Listing Service Agreement
0.0102 Loaded in seconds

We use cookies

We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on our website, to show you personalized content and targeted ads, to analyze our website traffic, and to understand where our visitors are coming from. Privacy Policy