Gettysburg Eddie's

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Gettysburg Eddie's

Story

A tribute to Edward Stewart Plank (aka: Gettysburg Eddie), Gettysburg's native son and baseball hall of famer. Stop in to learn more about Gettysburg Eddie and the era in which he played baseball. Also, visit our upstairs room; a tribute to 19th Century Base Ball and the "Elkton Eclipse" who introduced this new annual event to Gettysburg.

Address: 217 Steinwehr Ave, Gettysburg, PA 17325, USA

Phone: (717) 334-1100

Website

moc.seiddegrubsytteg@ofni

State: Pennsylvania

Zip Code: 17325

Update Info

Similar places near

Appalachian Brewing Co. 143 meter Great place to grab dinner. I had a fantastic burger and some poutine. Service was fr...

Reliance Mine Saloon 157 meter FUn little dive bar no frills just a friendly place to come too if you like blue coll...

O'Rorke's Family Eatery 278 meter Very busy but staff did the best they could to get us in on the time they gave us. Fo...

Farnsworth House Inn 502 meter We stayed one night, in the Custer Room, right off the garden. The room was comfortab...

Sweney's Tavern 512 meter Great atmosphere especially if you are interested in Gettysburg's history. Food was ...

Impressions Banquet Facility 700 meter I was surprised to learn that The Pike Restaurant had a banquet room, but am so glad ...

Pike Restaurant & Tap House 700 meter We went here around 3pm and it was easy to get into. We sat in the outdoor dining a...

Blue and Gray Bar & Grill 1 miles Decently priced and portioned. The service was fast, helpful and friendly. We got the...

Garryowen Irish Pub 1 miles We are vacationing in the area and stopped here because of the high reviews online an...

Knob Hall Winery Gettysburg 1 miles After a day or touring Gettysburg sit back & relax w/glass of their amazing wines. T...

The Parrot 1 miles What a way to make a comeback! My wife and I dined here nearly two months ago in Jun...

The Pub & Restaurant 1 miles Great place! At the height of lunch hour, we were seated quickly, order taken immedia...

Flying Bull, Inc. 1 miles Great little spot for drinks. Reasonable prices.

Mason Dixon Distillery 1 miles GREAT location, really cute restaurant. A little loud, it's all open and no insulatio...

Sharpshooters 2 miles Awesome cocktails. Great drink specials. Half price apps on Thursdays. The people are...

Ruby Tuesday 2 miles It's Ruby Tuesdays...food is good. Our server was great. Not sure why we had a 20 min...

TGI Fridays 2 miles I got the BBQ chicken salad, my wife got the Sizzling chicken with cheese. BBQ chick...

Karaoketraveler.com 2 miles

Reviews

This place has great food and awesome atmosphere. I took my eight-year-old and we had no problem finding something good for him to eat.

The staff was very outgoing and very friendly, usually something you find in most small towns but in this case it was extraordinary. So much so that I'm planning a trip just so I can come back to this place.

 8 years ago (22-11-2017)

I can't believe this place gets such high ratings. Must be shill reviews. Unfortunately, we chose this place while in Gettysburg based on those reviews. 

This place was unbelievably bad. Very slow service and stupidly overpriced food of poor quality and preparation. The fish tacos were an absolute joke. Take the fish from a McDonald's Filet O Fish, and put it on a Taco Bell soft taco, then make it even more inedible. The fish was so overcooked it was hard, soaked with grease, and rubbery on the inside. It was also COLD. The coleslaw and tarter sauce it came with had a crust forming over the top, clearly been sitting around awhile. 

The "Sizzling Salad" was described as a salad topped with grilled tenderloin. I figured it was be like any other good steak salad, with sliced grilled steak. Instead what I got was a plate of very wilted greens with tiny bits of meat, that were neither grilled nor tenderloin from what I could tell. They were just small, gristly, tough little bits of who knows what cut of meat. The accompanying "blue cheese" dressing was inedible congealed garbage that tasted like sour mayo. There was nothing even remotely blue cheese about it. I have no idea what flavor it was supposed to be. 

A really awful experience, waste of time, waste of money, and ruined an otherwise nice day in Gettysburg.

 8 years ago (25-11-2017)

Went for a drink last night and for lunch today. Awesome service, awesome cheese steak and bacon cheeseburger. We each got the seasoned waffle fries which were also very good. The owner (I believe he was) was a constant presence which is awesome we didn't communicate with him but being there and active in the business shows a lot ya know. We will come back during our next trip and certainly recommend!!

 8 years ago (26-08-2017)

First time visiting Gettysburg and was recommended this restaurant..I am so glad I listened! Incredible food and drinks and fun, laid back atmosphere. I got the wings and their special bloody mary. Yummy..can't wait to go back! I work as a destination marketer and have been sending other visitors to this restaurant!

 8 years ago (26-10-2017)

My wife and I had dinner and some cocktails here. The service was good and the food tasted amazing. The atmosphere was cozy and relaxing. We will definitely be going back.

 8 years ago (08-11-2017)

Comment on this business

Map, Satellite View
Street View

to add Gettysburg Eddie's map to your website;

<iframe width="450" height="300" src="https://us.a-better-place.com/v.php?seo=gettysburg-eddie-s&id=821014&yuk=300" frameborder="0"></iframe><p style="font-size:11px;margin-top:5px;"><a href="https://us.a-better-place.com/gettysburg-eddie-s-i821014.html" target="_blank" title="Gettysburg Eddie's">Gettysburg Eddie's</a></p>

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Gettysburg Eddie's

Story

Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

We use cookies