Mary Zifer Pizza

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Mary Zifer Pizza

Address: 145 2nd St NW, New Philadelphia, OH 44663, USA

Phone: (330) 343-1188

State: Ohio

Zip Code: 44663

Update Info

Similar places near

China Wok 278 meter Been going there since I was a kid. Love the food and quick service. Best Chinese foo...

Your Pizza Shop 351 meter Everything is exceptional great. Any food u order,, the price n quantity n quality .....

East of Chicago Pizza 1 miles Had the buffet today with my children and it was delicious and very hot!! I enjoy go...

Pizza Hut 1 miles I was seated promptly but server never showed up. I got & found my own silverware and...

Papa John's Pizza 1 miles Nasty pizza, plus "Pappa John" is a right wing nut job.

Domino's Pizza 2 miles Good pizza at a fair price. Speedy delivery and friendly workers. I

New Queen 327 miles Quick, delicious, fresh food with friendly service. Best fried chicken wings around! ...

New Ruby Chinese Restaurant 328 miles Food was quick but service was horrible. Food didn’t have too much flavor and was fai...

New Dennis Pizza 329 miles Has the best fried chicken in West Philadelphia!!!

New Star Express Pizza 329 miles Terrible service, I was an loyal customer but I'm done with this place I've been tryi...

Grateful Plate Meal Delivery & Catering 329 miles Very accommodating for personal preferences - received a call from the chef to discus...

New Germantown Pizza 332 miles Love this place! I been here a couple of times and the food is great along with fast ...

New London Pizza - Wyoming Ave 335 miles I like just ordered 4 pizza and 23 minutes later it's here. Now I no it's not always ...

Reviews

Worst. Pizza. Ever. Overall bland and without a lot of flavor, one topping left off that we ordered, and who ever heard of putting slices of yellow american cheese on pizza? The mushrooms were canned and soggy, the pepperoni lacked flavor and didn't crisp as it does on well cooked pizza, the crush look liked it was made from a pre-made store bought item. I've had better at WalMart.

 8 years ago (17-10-2017)

I want to start off this review by saying I eat Zifer's (in Dover) all the time. Good food, good prices. This is specifically for the New Philadelphia (CARRY OUT ONLY) store. I called in 2 orders of rigatoni and was told it would be over an hour. I've worked in many food serving establishments.. I understand each is different, and have different capabilities and ways of operation. However, I also know over an hour for 2 pasta dinners is absurd. I came in after waiting 40 minutes just to make sure my food wasn't getting cold because they over-quoted the time it would take. They hadn't even put it in yet. Told me is was for 8 o'clock and they hadn't even started it yet.. like.. are ya kidding me? I could have ordered from the Dover store, drove over, drove home, and eaten before they even started on my order at the New Phila location. Pathetic. 

 8 years ago (14-08-2017)

Lack customer service skills, can't pay with credit card, topping options minimal, crust is dry & tasteless.

 8 years ago (25-11-2017)

Unique pizza unlike any other I've had the past 20 years. It's a thick, crunchy crust with cheddar cheese and red sauce and then your toppings. The salads, while not terribly fancy, are great with the house dressing. I suggest a pepperoni and hamburger pizza or just pepperoni to try. Carry out only. 

 9 years ago (28-12-2016)

Great pizza that is homemade and NO PRESERVATIVES!!  ALL NATURAL!!

 8 years ago (22-05-2017)

Comment on this business

Map, Satellite View
Street View

to add Mary Zifer Pizza map to your website;

<iframe width="450" height="300" src="https://us.a-better-place.com/v.php?seo=mary-zifer-pizza&id=825038&yuk=300" frameborder="0"></iframe><p style="font-size:11px;margin-top:5px;"><a href="https://us.a-better-place.com/mary-zifer-pizza-i825038.html" target="_blank" title="Mary Zifer Pizza">Mary Zifer Pizza</a></p>

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Mary Zifer Pizza

Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

We use cookies