Brewster's Italian Cafe

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Brewster's Italian Cafe

Story

Address: 11 W Merchant St, New Buffalo, MI 49117, USA

Phone: (269) 469-3005

Website

moc.liamg@olaffubwensretswerb

State: Michigan

Zip Code: 49117

Update Info

Similar places near

David's Delicatessen & Coffee 48 meter David’s Reuben sandwich was wonderful! Big enough to split two ways for a light lunch...

Rosie's Restaurant 109 meter Returned here after a little more than a year and a half and was disappointed. Don'...

Casey's Bar & Grill 125 meter The food is above average. Unfortunately the prices are above average as well. I or...

SUBWAY®Restaurants 211 meter Michigan City Subway on 20 service is very very slow but the one on 421 going to Purd...

Villa Nova Pizzeria 259 meter If I could give negative stars, I would. We bought two kinds of pastas and two sauces...

Terrace Room 289 meter Asiago goat cheese and garlic bread appetizer is unreal! Rosemary Benedict is a top n...

The Stray Dog Bar & Grill 296 meter Wonderful experience. I've been coming to New Buffalo since 1995 and this is the firs...

Lake House Pub 319 meter Two hour wait at Stray Dog led us to a zero minute wait at this hidden gem. Delicious...

Song Asian Cuisine 333 meter Excellent sushi and atmosphere. Friendly staff. Perfect place to go as a couple or ...

New Buffalo Bills Wood Fired BBQ 720 meter This place is a must! From the other reviews you'll read the food is great and plent...

Redamak's 731 meter One of our family's all time favorite burger joints! Been patrons for 35+ years. Held...

Bentwood Tavern 749 meter Made reservations here after spending the day on the very nice New Buffalo Beach. The...

Jackie's Cafe 782 meter Just had breakfast at Jackie's Cafe - it was exceptional. Very clean and friendly st...

Pizza Hut 806 meter The waitress was super nice and friendly. They were busy with take-out, but our food ...

Roma Pizza 1 miles My friend and I decided to take a random exit and find a pizza place today (July 2017...

McDonald's 1 miles The cheese is never melted or even close to being warm on the breakfast sandwiches. ...

The Formal Fork 2 miles

Timbers Restaurant 2 miles Pretty tasty food. Good atmosphere, but be prepared to wait.

Reviews

I absolutely love the food here. A little pricey but well worth it. I have never had a poor experience here until yesterday. We had to wait for a table which is understandable and we were fine with waiting. We had a drink at the bar while waiting, the bartender was very friendly and made conversation with us. Our server on the other hand was also nice but we only saw her twice. She never offered us any bread or  even a salad. She brought us out our food and didn't see her again until we were finished. My boyfriend and I very rarely ever dress up, I felt since we are younger dressed in blue jeans and work boots we got pushed off to the side. I clearly saw her at other tables more often than ours. We went to pay I placed my card in the folder as she was standing at the table still and she then proceeded to walk away without it. I will be back again of course because I love the food, I won't let one bad experience ruin it for me.

 8 years ago (23-09-2017)

SARAH !!! Terrible service and manager!!! Claims she is the manager and wants to charge 20% gratuity for terrible service... then tells you I that it is written on the menu!!! It is illegal to charge that Gratuity for terrible service... especially when there are 3 adults and 2 kids!!! Then she tell you its included on the menu!!! WRONG!!!! In most places gratuity included is for parties of 8 or more at 18%!!! This place is a scam!!! The food was terrible and so is the service!! NEVER AGAIN!!

 8 years ago (27-11-2017)

Under rated in the neighbourhood. Everyone raves about the stray dog restaurant but the food here is high quality. A nice little out doorsy area too. The steak salad is a big win. Very generous portions. 

 8 years ago (10-09-2017)

The food was okay: good soup and pizza. The server was alright. The menu has little options. When the bill came it was up charged by 8 dollars for the pick two. The waitress had no idea why. We didn't order anything with up charges; this kinda leaves a bad taste in my mouth because how many people are up charged. I would expect more from a restaurant. No manger came to apologize. Overall provably not worth the money.

 8 years ago (12-06-2017)

We totally enjoyed Brewster's. Dan was our waiter and he was excellent. He offered bread ahead of the meal. He was attentive and refilled our drinks promptly. It was a bit pricey, but our servings were huge- sandwiches with salads. Desserts were yummy.  We will be returning to Brewster's.

 8 years ago (10-07-2017)

Comment on this business

Map, Satellite View
Street View

to add Brewster's Italian Cafe map to your website;

<iframe width="450" height="300" src="https://us.a-better-place.com/v.php?seo=brewster-s-italian-cafe&id=1033112&yuk=300" frameborder="0"></iframe><p style="font-size:11px;margin-top:5px;"><a href="https://us.a-better-place.com/brewster-s-italian-cafe-i1033112.html" target="_blank" title="Brewster's Italian Cafe">Brewster's Italian Cafe</a></p>

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Brewster's Italian Cafe

Story

Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

We use cookies