Mama Teresa's Pizzeria

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Mama Teresa's Pizzeria

Address: 1006 W Seneca St, Ithaca, NY 14850, USA

Phone: (607) 272-6262

Website

State: New York

Zip Code: 14850

Update Info

Similar places near

Sal's Pizzeria 507 meter JOE AND SAL ARE SIMPLY THE BEST. GENTLEMAN THAT SERVE GREAT ITAILIAN FOOD IN THE HEA...

Ithaca Bakery 508 meter Good food..but american style. If you are looking for eggs on homemade thick crunchy ...

Chili's Grill & Bar 899 meter Food and service is always amazing wait staff is great. Best Corp chain restaurant in...

Papa John's Pizza 1 miles The delivery person was rude. Maybe they can be trained in customer service & how to ...

D.P. Dough - Ithaca 1 miles I am not a calzone fan, unless it's from d.p. dough. I love their calzones. If you ...

Firehouse Subs 1 miles For what could be described as a fast food chain, the customer service here is impecc...

Mark's Pizzeria 1 miles Taste like bad gas station pizza , even the texture of the crust is pretty sad.. wors...

Jimmy John's 1 miles Fast Service, Good Subs, Better Pizza, Papa John's

Moe's Southwest Grill 1 miles Best value for your money, for this kind of food, especially on Moe Monday (every Mon...

Domino's Pizza 1 miles Great customer service, fast delivery, excellent food. I love this place and will nev...

Gateway BBQ Kitchen 1 miles The barbecue is incredible! Absolutely delicious. There isn't a lot of indoor seating...

Napoli Pizzeria 1 miles I have been a faithful customer to Napoli's for many years. Delivery, pick-up, even e...

Godfather's Pizza 1 miles

Luna Inspired Street Food Collegetown 1 miles I've always had good experiences ordering from here. However, what puts Luna above is...

Jack's Grill 1 miles I ordered something with my Mom and we got everything we ordered in good working orde...

Apollo 1 miles I was fairly surprised by their seafood soup. The seafood was fresh and delicious. Th...

Italian Carry Out 2 miles This is by far the best pizza in town. Nothing beats their pizza with the sauce on t...

Pizza Hut 3 miles So, the pizza at Pizza Hut is delicious. It always is. They even had a great Saturd...

Reviews

Wanted to order pizzas on the way through Ithaca, ordered ahead of the time, placed it online. Glad I chose cash. Got there - lights on, food out, even their two "Open" signs flashing... But no one there, doors locked. After I got there- had gotten a call from 'Slice' telling me they couldn't confirm, as no one answered for them either.

 8 years ago (08-10-2017)

Had one tasty slice of pizza here, but the second one gave me a stomachache​. Probably won't go back.

 8 years ago (04-06-2017)

I ordered something called Canadian french fries. I myself am candian. The French fries had gravy on them that tasted like it hadn't been mixed properly. It was the saltier thing I have ever tasted, PURE salt. When I called and asked to speak to the manager I got a man on the phone with an accent. I explained it was too salty and asked if I could get a different order of it another time that wasn't made this way. He said well maybe next time you shouldn't order gravy on it, this is the gravy I use for everything. I said, please do me a favor a taste test your gravy and tell me that it's not our salt. He said well I said next time just don't order gravy on your fries if you think it's too salty. He was extremely rude and in no way wanting to accommodate or meet  in the middle with me. So I said is there a different manager I can speak with, your being very rude. So I said nevermind, I will call tomorrow and speak with a different manager. Thank you, have a nice day. And hung up. Based off of this... I don't think I would ever order from them again.

 9 years ago (18-04-2016)

We ordered the chicken parm and chicken alfredo. Both were very soupy and oily, it was disgusting. Also, both meals were supposed to come with garlic knots and we did not receive them. Upon calling the restaurant to request the garlic knots that I paid for, the staff member gave me extreme attitude and difficulty. I am a college student here and trying to find decent food late night is difficult but I will never order from this place again.  This rate and review makes you put a star level in order to post the comment but if I could, I would give it 0 stars.

 9 years ago (11-04-2016)

Been looking for good Italian Pizza since moving to the area, I ordered a smattering of desserts all were good, cannoli, éclair, fried dough, the antipasti salad was a but small but for the price I would say fair with LOTS of meats and cheese and the traditional fixings, the pizza was disappointing I ordered a slice of Sicilian Pizza and received a slice of thin crust regular pizza.  I have to say the sauce was EXCELLENT - this coming from an NJ Italian =)  Will give them a second chance.  Was 45 min for delivery on a Saturday - pretty average for Ithaca.

 9 years ago (31-01-2016)

Comment on this business

Map, Satellite View
Street View

to add Mama Teresa's Pizzeria map to your website;

<iframe width="450" height="300" src="https://us.a-better-place.com/v.php?seo=mama-teresa-s-pizzeria&id=794463&yuk=300" frameborder="0"></iframe><p style="font-size:11px;margin-top:5px;"><a href="https://us.a-better-place.com/mama-teresa-s-pizzeria-i794463.html" target="_blank" title="Mama Teresa's Pizzeria">Mama Teresa's Pizzeria</a></p>

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Mama Teresa's Pizzeria

Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

We use cookies