Milk Bar Midtown

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Milk Bar Midtown

Address: 15 W 56th St, New York, NY 10019, USA

Phone: (646) 634-5627

Website

State: New York

City: New York

Zip Code: 10019

Opening Hours

Monday: 8:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Tuesday: 8:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Wednesday: 8:00 AM – 11:00 PM
Thursday: 8:00 AM – 12:00 AM
Friday: 8:00 AM – 12:00 AM
Saturday: 8:00 AM – 12:00 AM
Sunday: 8:00 AM – 12:00 AM

Update Info

Similar places near

Billy's Bakery 221 meter Was super hungry and found the food hall at The Plaza. I love cupcakes so bought one ...

Magnolia Bakery 591 meter This is a quick spot to pick up a sweet treat in the area, most importantly the banan...

Bouchon Bakery 601 meter Slow servers with a moderately friendly attitude. Great pastries and coffee sandwich ...

Sprinkles Cupcakes 652 meter It was my first time. they have so many good stuff that you can't pick one. The staff...

Magnolia Bakery 756 meter What a good spot for a bakery! Though Bloomingdale's might not be open, the doors to ...

Bouchon Bakery & Café 872 meter The parfait I had here was marvelous!! Their croissants are also very good. It's a ni...

Breads Bakery 1 miles The Chocolate Babka is incredible! The customer service is also top-notch. Although t...

Birdbath Bakery 1 miles In a paper cup, I received my ladled hot cocoa with a corner of large white cubed mar...

Magnolia Bakery 1 miles We got lucky: 1) It opened on the day we went; 2) There was no line at all. The egg t...

Amy's Bread 1 miles I was in NYC on vacation on a Sunday morning looking for a quick place to chill out a...

Schmackary's 1 miles Nice little cookie store, with an interesting rotation of cookies. The price is good ...

Magnolia Bakery 1 miles Went with a birthday party that my daughter was attending. I know the cupcakes are co...

Zaro's Family Bakery 1 miles Picked up a custom order Shadow cake from Zaro's for the holidays. It was pretty good...

Maison Kayser 1 miles My favorite breakfast / brunch spot. Amazing pastries. Great bread to take home or m...

Sullivan Street Bakery 1 miles The line is very long but the wait is worth it if you are a fan of egg tarts....the f...

Birdbath Bakery 1 miles It’s a very quiet Monday, not too busy but the basics have let this place down. Every...

Zaro's Family Bakery 1 miles What makes stop here is the great attitude, service, friendliness and quite frankly t...

Levain Bakery 1 miles I went in on a Friday afternoon and didn't have to wait in line at all. The cookies a...

Reviews

First off this place is nearly impossible to find! We walked around the block 3 times before we found it. It is a tiny unmarked door next to giant beautiful wooden doors, you’re welcome. My boyfriend and I got the famous cereal milk corn flake soft serve and a chocolate pretzel soft serve... what we want to know is why was everything SO salty! The girls behind the counter knew my boyfriend hated his and did not a single thing to offer for him to try something else. That’s definitely what bothered me the most seeing as we both work in food and beverage in the hospitality industry. 

Glad we went but not worth the money, better off at Ben and Jerry’s!

 8 years ago (11-03-2018)

Well, to be completely honest...I think in order to enjoy this unique place you need to be someone who likes bad things. You need to be that guy who thinks that The Room is a good movie. I hate cereal, I know...that I can’t help. But that shouldn’t leave me with one option on the menu. So I got the chocolate pretzel ice cream. I took one bite and it took me back to a 5th grade family trip at the beach when I swallowed way too much salt water. This was frozen salt water straight from the Atlantic with a dash of chocolate. My girlfriend’s cereal ice cream came from the Dead Sea. We took one bite each and threw it out at the next trashcan we saw. Place looks hip though!

 8 years ago (10-03-2018)

Definitley my favorite dessert place. Was disappointed last time though as my milkshake was only about 3/4 of the way full. Not sure why they wouldn’t just fill it all the way up. Maybe the ice cream comes out of their pay? Not sure. The cereal ice cream itself though is the best.

 9 years ago (10-02-2018)

Delicious stuff! Got their soft serve ice cream which was creamy and tasty. Got cereal milk and cinnamon something for flavors swirled together. Got one of their famous compost cookies which has like everything in it which makes eating it fun because every bite is different and also got their crack pie. If nothing else get the crack pie! Also tasted the coffee shake off a friend and that was amazing one of the best I've ever had. Cake balls are yummy as well. Delicious! Limited selection, not traditionally made stuff so not for picky close minded people.

 9 years ago (22-08-2017)

I almost missed this place when I was trying to find it a few days back. I wish I had missed it.
Nestled away in a small but uniquely decorated location, I was excited to try their equally unique assortment of flavors.
I tried the chocolate pretzel soft serve, three things I am a huge fan of. From the first bite, something felt off. It tasted almost like it had caramel in it. That's fine but I tried another bite. Nope, not caramel. Salt? A few bites later, I realized it tasted like spoilt milk. I couldn't eat more than those three bites.
I hoped the cookies would be better, but no luck. Just that same salty, disgusting flavor.
Maybe this flavor is something that they're known and loved for, but I now know them and hate them for it.

      
      
      
 9 years ago (20-12-2017)

Comment on this business

Map, Satellite View
Street View

to add Milk Bar Midtown map to your website;

<iframe width="450" height="300" src="https://us.a-better-place.com/v.php?seo=milk-bar-midtown&id=107440&yuk=300" frameborder="0"></iframe><p style="font-size:11px;margin-top:5px;"><a href="https://us.a-better-place.com/milk-bar-midtown-i107440.html" target="_blank" title="Milk Bar Midtown">Milk Bar Midtown</a></p>

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Milk Bar Midtown

Opening Hours

Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

We use cookies