New York Pizza Exchange

Reviews, get directions and contact details for New York Pizza Exchange

Address: 2810 Paces Ferry Rd SE #102, Atlanta, GA 30339, USA

Phone: (770) 434-9000

Website

State: Georgia

Zip Code: 30339

Update Info

Similar places near

Firehouse Subs 1 miles Not sure how a sub with no tomato turns into a sandwich on non-sub bread, but some ho...

Wingstop 2 miles The best flavor on the board is Louisiana rub hands down. The staff is very friendly...

Marco's Pizza 3 miles This is the most unprofessional pizza restaurant I ever ordered from. I place an orde...

Johnny's New York Style Pizza 4 miles I've been eating at Johnny's for 30 years, but this was my first visit to this locati...

New Dragon 5 miles Food was not good as expected, I got crab rangoon and a seafood deluxe. Crab wasn't r...

Malaya 5 miles I have eaten here for 10 plus years. This is my top choice place for Asian food aroun...

Yoiyoi Steak House and Sushi 5 miles The food was great! I ordered the tempura Philadelphia roll and lobster rangoons for ...

Zoës Kitchen 5 miles Tasty food but very small portions

Papa John's Pizza 5 miles We are a business 2 miles down the road and we love to order a few pizzas on the week...

Wing Factory 5 miles I love the Wing Factory. The chicken wings are good (but not the best I've ever had) ...

Rosati's Pizza and Sports Pub 5 miles I went for lunch with my husband and kids. We sat on the heated patio. The music was ...

Wok N Roll Restaurant 5 miles It took the driver 45 minutes to deliver once we had the notification that he had lef...

Atlanta Meal Prep, LLC. 5 miles

Canton Buddha Restaurant 5 miles The reason why I am rating a three star because the manager who was my server has not...

Marco's Pizza 6 miles We usually go to this place for lunch. They have a lunch special that's 1 small 1 top...

Instead of Flowers, Inc. 6 miles Staff is awesomely welcoming and I’ve had a great time working with the culinary team...

Jack's New Yorker Deli 6 miles Delicious!!! Will come back. Their souls are incredible, make sure you try the parmes...

Buckhead Pizza Co. 6 miles Really enjoyed this place. Great pizza, fantastic salad with incredible dressing, an...

Reviews

My girlfriend and I are there tonight and we we're both really hungry. Service was great to begin with, but the meal went down hill from there. The ceaser didn't seem special, and then the pepperoni rolls came out. They were raw in the middle. We sent them back, the garlic bread came out which was okay. It was a little over seasoned in my opinion but It was okay. The rolls came back out and were raw again and the server didn't come back out to ask how they were until a long time later when my two slices of pizza came out. Both of which (one new York on Sicilian) were raw. We didn't send these back because we were starving at this point (over an hour wait time). Overall it was a very poor experience and made both of our stomach sick within 15 minutes of leaving the restaurant.

 8 years ago (25-08-2017)

The delivery driver got so pissed with me because I didn't tip. I work in a cupcake shop and offered him some cupcakes. He yells " I don't want the cupcakes you can keep that! I want the tip!" He storms out of the store. I don't know, maybe it me but when did people start being so aggressive about a tip. I would have given him $2 for tip. If that's worth being angry over then I don't know. I'll probably never order from here again. I also don't think I should've charge $6 for something that's frozen and just heated up... the macaroni and cheese bites are awful. Pizza is ok because I'm hungry but it's salty and picklish. Ugh! $30 I spent at this place.

 8 years ago (18-10-2017)

Ha! This place was awesome....then came .... something, I don't know; things changed. Food quality and delivery is terribly inconsistent, leaving you dissatisfied more often than a cpl years ago. Service is always piss poor though, I'm talking lower than the  piss poor service you get from any establishment within 20 mins of the Atlanta Metro area. *Breathe* 

So about the food, on a good day you'll get noddles that aren't overcooked, marinara that taste of tomatoes AND spices AND seasoning, meat that is cooked and palpable, and bread that is cooked properly with amazing garlic butter. 

On an average day, you can expect your pasta to be strained, but not drained (swimmin' in water), your pizza will be slightly undercooked, and any special requests to your order will go ignored. 

Delivery is always quick. Deliverer always expects a generous tip. Expect no plastic-wear with your delivery order.  

Desserts are usually a miss; I've ordered cheesecake that was so dry on one side of it, I knew it'd been sitting in some fridge for at least a week. 

Still, as awful as this review seems they are the best Italian (or whatever) spot in the Cumberland/Vinings/Smyrna area. (compared to saaaay, Mezza Luna ....that place is atrocious!!)

 8 years ago (10-09-2017)

Specifically asked not to have any cucumbers or carrots in my salad. Bruschetta on a hoagie... Who does that? And, there was so much water in my spaghetti and meatballs you can swim in it. I hope they appreciate my measly $25 because it is my first and last time ever eating from this place.

 8 years ago (05-09-2017)

We ordered delivery. $40 for a pizza and cesaer salad. The pizza was terrible, the cheese tastes like plastic goo. The salad was all bread and croutons with hardly any salad. The lettuce was warm because they put the salad in a breadbowl. I think it's cute in a creative way, but I wanted a large crisp cesaer salad. I'm really disappointed. We can't eat pizza very often due to dietary restrictions so this was supposed to be a treat for us. I ordered the plain cheese in the past and that was good. I'll probably stick to that. We pretty much three it all away. 

 8 years ago (28-08-2017)

Comment on this business

Map, Satellite View
Street View

to add New York Pizza Exchange map to your website;

<iframe width="450" height="300" src="https://us.a-better-place.com/v.php?seo=new-york-pizza-exchange&id=423481&yuk=300" frameborder="0"></iframe><p style="font-size:11px;margin-top:5px;"><a href="https://us.a-better-place.com/new-york-pizza-exchange-i423481.html" target="_blank" title="New York Pizza Exchange">New York Pizza Exchange</a></p>

New York Pizza Exchange

Reviews, get directions and contact details for New York Pizza Exchange

Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

We use cookies