Pudgies Pizza

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Pudgies Pizza

Address: 134 W Franklin St, Horseheads, NY 14845, USA

Phone: (607) 739-8781

Website

State: New York

Zip Code: 14845

Update Info

Similar places near

Thai Asian 119 53 meter It's pretty good. Good service, decent food, reasonable prices.

PDR's Catering 840 meter This is an amazing Catering Company and the owner Penny is a Diamond, she is such an ...

Giuseppe's 1 miles My husband and I are from Buffalo, N.Y. and Giuseppes is hands down the BEST Italian ...

Rico's Pizza & Subs 1 miles I order eggplant parm sub and pc of veggy pizza! I have had eggplant everywhere and R...

SUBWAY®Restaurants 1 miles last night there was a red haired girl who was professional and food was good but all...

Pizza Pick Up 1 miles BEST *extra, extra, extra hot boneless wings my family and I have ever had. Wonderful...

Picnic Pizza 1 miles I've given Picnic Pizza multiple chances to make up for consistent mistakes made duri...

Dragon Wok 1 miles Luckily for the owners. There isn't much competition for their restaurants in the are...

SUBWAY®Restaurants 1 miles This is a great Subway. Every time I have been here in the past year the employees ar...

Denny's 1 miles My visits to Denny's is most always breakfast with Nick, Jack the cook and Carol. The...

Domino's Pizza 1 miles Quality is always good, place is very clean, and everyone is friendly. Highly recomme...

Schwan Food Co 2 miles

Mary Buchtel's Party Shop 2 miles

SUBWAY®Restaurants 2 miles

Blimpie 3 miles Great food and people.

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant 3 miles Servers were very friendly, and the food was good. My Seafood Carbonara could have ha...

Chili's Grill & Bar 3 miles Last weekend I went to this Chili’s with some of the cast and crew of my High School’...

SUBWAY®Restaurants 3 miles No experience

Reviews

Don't bother with this place. 

Typical chain--all about throughput. To say that you can't control what you get in is one thing. But you can control what you put out the door. 

Half of the wings we got looked like someone took a bite and half of the meat was gone. 

I know that I won't be going here again and I suggest others do the same.

 8 years ago (08-06-2017)

Horseheads Pudgies seems to be a polarizing pizzeria for the locals; you either love it or you hate it.  This place has always been my favorite pizza since I was a young tike.  The haters like to call it Sludgies.  I will admit that the prices are high, but you simply cannot beat the taste/flavor in my opinion.  They use a lot more sauce and cheese than the average pizzeria and that can create a lot of grease (hence Sludgies).  The crust is more of a fluffy chewy variety as opposed to most of the New York style thin crisp crusts in the area.  The crust is also the same consistency and texture for their small - large sizes, and for their sheet pizza.  For instance, if you go to Picnic Pizza and order a sheet pizza, it is a completely different crust than their large pizza.  I also love the wings at Horseheads Pudgies, but make sure you get the traditional and not the boneless, the boneless are very similar to Buffalo Wild Wings and I am not a fan of that style.  I don't order from Pudgies as much as I would like to due to the high prices, but when I do I always get one of their combo packs.   Their Square Deal is a large pizza, 20 wings and a quart of soda.  The Party pack is a sheet pizza with 20 wings and a quart of soda.  Or if you want to go all out, the Max Pack is a sheet pizza, 40 wings and 2 quarts of soda.  I recommend pepperoni and meat sauce for the pizza and mild traditional wings.

They also offer pizza by the slice, breadsticks, hot and cold subs, other fried foods, pastas, salads, stromboli and calzones.

Again, the prices are high, but you get what you pay for.  Quality always costs a bit more, and your taste buds will thank you for it!

 7 years ago (31-08-2017)

Love the Stromboli. Pizza has good flavor. Very crusty or bready crust. But not under cooked I like thicker crust so this pizza is perfect for me

 8 years ago (23-06-2017)

The food quality is classic Pudgies. The garbage needed attention, as did the bathroom cleanliness. This place is always busy with locals. 

 8 years ago (07-07-2017)

Very nice pudgies location clean and lots of places to sit stromboli was delicious!  

 7 years ago (29-08-2017)

Comment on this business

Map, Satellite View
Street View

to add Pudgies Pizza map to your website;

<iframe width="450" height="300" src="https://us.a-better-place.com/v.php?seo=pudgies-pizza&id=950057&yuk=300" frameborder="0"></iframe><p style="font-size:11px;margin-top:5px;"><a href="https://us.a-better-place.com/pudgies-pizza-i950057.html" target="_blank" title="Pudgies Pizza">Pudgies Pizza</a></p>

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Pudgies Pizza

Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

We use cookies