NYPD Pizzeria

Reviews, get directions and contact details for NYPD Pizzeria

"Casual local chain with East Coast-style, thin-crust pizzas, calzones & local brews on tap."

Address: 16118 Marsh Rd , Winter Garden 34787, FL, US

Phone: (407) 877-4743

State: FL

City: Winter Garden

Zip Code: 34787

Update Info

related searches: NYPD Pizza Winter Garden menu, NYPD Pizza menu, NYPD Pizza Orlando, Best pizza Winter Garden, NYPD Pizza Near me, NYPD Pizza The Villages, NYPD Pizza Tuesday special, NYPD Pizza specials

Similar places near

Pizza Hut 307 meter We are here visiting Orlando and decided to do delivery from Pizza Hut to make things...

Domino's Pizza 367 meter Tried to order on a Sunday. On hold 15 minutes. Drove over and placed the order in ...

Uno Pizzeria & Grill 2 miles Translated by Google I stopped by for lunch on my way to Taga Taisha because I could ...

Little Caesars Pizza 3 miles The pizza was chewy and tasted like it was there for more than an 2hr in the warmer. ...

Italian Garden Pizzeria 3 miles

Pinotti's Pizza® 3 miles Pinotti’s Pizza in Winter Garden Central Florida about 15 minutes of downtown Orlando...

Marco's Pizza 3 miles I just went to this location tonight my first time at Marco's Pizza & Jess and he...

Michael's Ali Coal Fired Pizza 4 miles First and last home. We had heard about how great this pizza was…unfortunately we di...

Mangoni 4 miles I was so happy to dine at this location as I remember the construction when it was be...

Pammie's Sammies 4 miles My husband has been wanting to try Pammie’s Sammies for awhile. They did not disappoi...

Winter Garden Pizza Company 4 miles If this had been my first visit, it would have also been my last. Normally I’d give ...

Reviews

Good food! Okay service.  Had two very good pizzas, a house salad, and the garlic cheese bread. All were very good. The server was just okay. She never introduced herself by name. We had to ask for drink refills and she just wasn’t really around when we needed her.  Over all I would try this place again. The server could have just been having an off day.

The restaurant is pretty good. The best vegan option is a build your own pizza with an assortment of veggies. I was happy to see that they didn’t skimp out on any veggies so it really made up for the lack of vegan cheeses. The sauce was just okay but the crust was pretty good.  Staff was very friendly and were upfront about the wait time their estimate was spot on for us which was much appreciated. However, the restaurant is incredibly under staffed. It took a while to place an order because the woman at the cash register had so much to do. I hope they are able to find additional staff.

I was excited to see a NY style pizza place in my travels on my route.  The pizza was okay.  Definitely a very big slice but true NY Pizza, especially when reheating a slice, should have a very crispy crust.  This crust had no crispness to it at all.  Would I eat it again? Yes, but I wouldn't go out of my way for it. It was a decent slice but when it comes to pizza, the crust makes all the difference.

We ate in tonight and had a great experience! Mindy is the best! Celebrated a friends birthday with a party of 12 and the service was perfect. Food was great. Highly recommend the wings crispy. Definitely coming back and will hopefully have the same server.

I’ve always loved NYPD pizza and still love the food but most recently we dined in and we were served with a white girl, blond hair with an accent who seemed not happy to be there. We asked for lemon with our water and when the water came out had no lemon, ok people forget but when asked again she said she was busy doing other stuff and will get around to it. We had to remind her two more times and after 15 min we finally got our lemon for our water something so simple. She never checked on our table. Gave us our food with a frown on her face and when we would say thank you she would just walk away, as if she doesn’t know how to “you’re welcome”. She was not a good waitress and left us with a bad dine in experience. But the food was good, pricey but good.

I was extremely disappointed with there pizza .. This  was my second visit after just moving to the area.  The pizzas were flavorless , the ratio of dough & cheese are skimpy. For the price they charge you would think you were more of a higher quality product.. and I was also told by a cashier they just raised prices.  For what you get they should be lowered!!  This is no where close to NY style pizza!!

This is the second time we went there and he went to order our food but the lady taking our order was super rude. When we were telling her no ricotta she rudely interrupted stating that we don’t know what we are ordering. Then when we went to get our food she told us it wasn’t ready then magically pulls it out saying it’s been ready for a bit. We got home and two of our thing where wrong. We asked for spinach and mushroom and she gave us pepperoni and ham. We then proceeded to call stating are food was wrong and we were just in there, the lady who took ate order was on the other end of the line saying it’s in there it’s just hidden. News flash it was not in there what’s so ever. Would not like to go there again.

Delicious and fresh New York style pizza. We absolutely love the garlic knots! The food is always great, the staff however seems to change a lot. We e had great servers and not so great servers. We love the Tuesday night special of buy one pizza get one free! They have great deserts too.

Amazing NY Pizza the owner is very nice amd welcoming and a New Yorker moved south like us

Mixed experience, not what we expected. We decided to try out this place for some NY style pizza. The pizza was hard and chewy, what some may call cardboard pizza. They need to revamp the dough recipe it seems.  The service was slow and unfriendly. Our server has no customer service skills and clearly did not want to be there.  Plenty of seating here with NY decor.  Unfortunately, we would not return here. Way better options are out there for the money.

Comment on this business

Map, Satellite View
Street View

to add NYPD Pizzeria map to your website;

<iframe width="450" height="300" src="https://us.a-better-place.com/v.php?seo=nypd-pizzeria&id=1980162&yuk=300" frameborder="0"></iframe><p style="font-size:11px;margin-top:5px;"><a href="https://us.a-better-place.com/nypd-pizzeria-i1980162.html" target="_blank" title="NYPD Pizzeria">NYPD Pizzeria</a></p>

Reviews, get directions and contact details for NYPD Pizzeria

Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

We use cookies