facebooktwitterpinterest
mobil menu

The Old Mill Pottery House Café & Grille

  1. Tennessee
  2. Pigeon Falls Food

Reviews, get directions and contact details for The Old Mill Pottery House Café & Grille

Address: 3341 Old Mill St, Pigeon Forge, TN 37863, USA
Phone: (865) 453-6002
State: Tennessee
Zip Code: 37863


Update Info
Similar places near
The Old Mill Restaurant The Old Mill Restaurant 111 meter I loved the old mill. The restaurant itself was nice, and even though it was busy we ...
SUBWAY®Restaurants SUBWAY®Restaurants 477 meter Staff was friendly . Sandwiches were good. We enjoyed our visit.
Food City Food City 614 meter We visited from North Carolina. The sale prices posted are only good with the store...
IHOP IHOP 705 meter Delicious!! I had a bad experience at ihop years ago and was never willing to give it...
Arby's Arby's 788 meter This location could use a little work on speed. It took a little long but was well wo...
Denny's Denny's 985 meter It's Denny's. The food is predictable, but good. The place was crowded but they man...
Alamo Steak House Alamo Steak House 1 miles I asked the our server if the steaks were aged in house and he looked very confused a...
Mama's Farmhouse Mama's Farmhouse 1 miles I really don't understand all of these amazing reviews for this place. Our family ate...
Bennett's Pit Bar-B-Que Bennett's Pit Bar-B-Que 1 miles Excellent BBQ ribs. The lunch portion with an added salad bar is more than you need ...
Waffle House Waffle House 1 miles My eggs were a little over done and our server forgot our sausage and bacon. In her d...
Smoky Mountain Pancake House Smoky Mountain Pancake House 1 miles Are there today for breakfast. Consistently brought wrong items ordered. Had to ask t...
Sawyer's Farmhouse Breakfast Sawyer's Farmhouse Breakfast 1 miles Delicious food - long wait time. We came for a late breakfast, and the wait was ove...
Frizzle Chicken Farmhouse Cafe Frizzle Chicken Farmhouse Cafe 1 miles Came back for supper. This place is great. Our server was Missy and she went out of h...
Margaritaville Restaurant Pigeon Forge Margaritaville Restaurant Pigeon Forge 1 miles Very nice atmosphere. I was in the mood for a good margarita and this should be the p...
Wild Bear Tavern Wild Bear Tavern 1 miles I would say this is your very average pancake house with extraordinarily big pancakes...
Paula Deen's Family Kitchen Paula Deen's Family Kitchen 1 miles Beware Beware you Will over eat this is by far the best restaurant I have ever ate a...
Flapjacks Pancake Cabin Flapjacks Pancake Cabin 1 miles Food and service were very good...didn't care for the sales pitch on the way out. Do...
Dick's Last Resort Dick's Last Resort 1 miles I know the service is suppose to be bad. But your food shouldn't be bad. We had the f...
Reviews
This was the most delicious food we had in Pigeon Forge! The only reason it gets 4 stars instead of 5 is that there was always a wait of 45-75 minutes while we were in town, and they don't take reservations or call-ahead seating. Pros: 1. Wonderful food. I got the Old Forge's Whiskey Burger, and it was a knife-and-fork type burger...huge and delicious. I tried a little from all the entrees at the table, and everything was tasty. We also had the pimiento cheese, and we liked it so much we ordered some for take-out a few days later. I don't even like pimiento cheese, but theirs was just fabulous! 2. Lovely patio dining. We ate on the patio, and while it was hot in front of the building, we were very comfortable at our table. When I walked through the patio a few days later after it had cooled down, they had heaters out keeping the temperature cozy. 3. Text paging. They took my phone number when I went to the host station. I received an immediate text showing that they had my number right. Then I could sit in the chairs in the courtyard or wander through the nearby shops until I received a text saying that our table was ready. Cons: 1. No reservations. There was always a wait, even at times that are off-hours for most restaurants. It would be nice to be able to make a reservation instead of waiting on site. We waited over an hour for our table. 2. Crazy host station. There was a long, crowded line going to the host station when we first checked in. Once we received a text, it was hard to find someone to take us to our table. They were very busy, but didn't seem to be moving very fast at the host station. 3. Takeout. We called in an order of pimiento cheese to go, and it was ready in 20 minutes. The wait time for a table then was about 45 minutes. Overall, thumbs up!! I would definitely return if I am in Pigeon Forge again. We would have eaten there more times during our visit if we could have made a reservation.
9 years ago (19-10-2017)
One of the most fantastic places I've ever eaten. It's better than "The Old Mill" restaurant across the street, meals here are made for every order so a lot more care goes in. I happened to eat here twice, our waiters were kind and one of them was very fun and charismatic. The food was in the top tier, I had the Pimento Cheese BLT which was highly flavorful and delicious. Among their salads I tried the House Caesar Salad which was one of the best Caesar salads I've had in a long time. They have a side item which you may consider strange but it is absolutely something to try, the Jalapeno Corn Pudding. I also had the Grilled Salmon which was delicious with is wild rice and sauce and I tried some tomato basil soup which was highly perfected in both flavor and creamy consistency. The restaurant carries both raspberry and peach iced tea and both were delicious. The thing that struck me the most about this particular place though was that they grind their own grain, bake their own bread, and craft their own plates and bowls. The establishment also has a lovely pottery shop a few doors down. The last thing I want to say about The Old Mill Pottery House is the outdoors atmosphere which felt so relaxing with the running water and landscaping as well as the cozy trees above. Please visit this restaurant before any other in Pigeon Forge, it's fantastic and it's kind of like a hidden gem known by the locals.
9 years ago (10-06-2017)
My family has been going to this restaurant for years and we keep coming back to to it year after year. We love the atmosphere and outside seating. It has a beautiful outside garden dining area. The food is always good and service polite. All the dishes are made at the Old Mill Pottery Shop next door. The bread is baked fresh in house. Great choice if you are in the Smokey Mountain area.
9 years ago (04-08-2017)
Amazing! My hubby and I ordered pecan chicken breast with a sweet potato, yummy! The bread is to die for too! Our male waiter also gave us excellent service! Would recommend this place if your visiting in Pigeon Forge.
9 years ago (01-11-2017)
The food is very good and always tastes great. Hostess lost our reservations and acted like we did not give our name to her but another lady came over and did remember us. The waitress was not very friendly and seemed to just go through the motions, no people skills. The home made bread $6.10 a loaf but very good. I would go back for the food but they need better people who take time to care about the customers.
9 years ago (31-07-2017)
Comment on this business

The Old Mill Pottery House Café & Grille map

to add The Old Mill Pottery House Café & Grille map to your website;



Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

Copyright 2025 | All rights reserved (v2)

Terms Of Service
Privacy Policy
Business Listing Service Agreement
0.0305 Loaded in seconds

We use cookies

We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on our website, to show you personalized content and targeted ads, to analyze our website traffic, and to understand where our visitors are coming from. Privacy Policy