facebooktwitterpinterest
mobil menu

Kay Jewelers

  1. Wisconsin
  2. Wisconsin Jewelry Store

Reviews, get directions and contact details for Kay Jewelers

Story

Since 1916, Kay Jewelers has grown from one store to more than 1,100 from coast to coast. As the #1 jewelry store in America, we know that offering fine jewelry at a great price is only part of the story. We are fully committed to providing a superior shopping experience - both in our stores and online. Our jewelry consultants are empowered with the knowledge to assist each guest. Shop our selection of engagement rings, wedding rings, diamonds, gemstones, gold, contemporary metals, watches and more. Kay Jewelers carries a wide selection of famous name brand styles, including Ever Us™, Neil Lane Bridal®, The Leo Diamond®, Tolkowsky® diamonds and Le Vian Chocolate Diamonds®. Come visit your Kay Jewelers in Wauwatosa today.

Address: 2500 N Mayfair Rd, Wauwatosa, WI 53226, USA
Phone: (414) 257-0353
State: Wisconsin
City: Wauwatosa
Zip Code: 53226


Opening Hours

Monday: 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Tuesday: 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Wednesday: 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Thursday: 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Friday: 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Saturday: 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Sunday: 12:00 – 5:00 PM

Update Info
Similar places near
Treiber & Straub Jewelers Treiber & Straub Jewelers 3 miles Fabulous experience! Been looking for a new watch for a while and had visited anothe...
J.P. Haase Jewelers J.P. Haase Jewelers 3 miles Great prices and selection Cheap prices on diamonds Great personal service
Shallow Jewelers Shallow Jewelers 3 miles I went here upon a recommendation and was very excited walking into the store. I told...
Kay Jewelers Kay Jewelers 4 miles Not even giving it 1 star, but have to in order to post. Customer service is horrible...
Jared The Galleria of Jewelry Jared The Galleria of Jewelry 4 miles We started working with Jared over 3 years ago to find a custom diamond for an engage...
Sullivan Jewelers Sullivan Jewelers 4 miles I needed my engagement ring resized. They were very nice and gave me a great price an...
The Jewelry Center The Jewelry Center 4 miles Primarily used TJC for watch battery changes until I needed to buy an engagement ring...
Kesslers Diamonds - Brookfield Kesslers Diamonds - Brookfield 5 miles Kesslers is fantastic! I designed my engagement ring gave them the color of my diamon...
Tobin Jewelers Inc Tobin Jewelers Inc 7 miles Amazing jewelry and personalized service from a family owned company. Their quality c...
Powers Jewelry Designers Powers Jewelry Designers 7 miles This family owned business is the best experience in Milwaukee for all your jewelry n...
Schwanke-Kasten Jewelers Schwanke-Kasten Jewelers 7 miles It was my first time in the downtown store and wanted to get my battery changed on my...
The Jewelry Center The Jewelry Center 8 miles This is the only local jewelry store I use. I have been coming to The Jewelry Centers...
Kesslers Diamonds - Greenfield Kesslers Diamonds - Greenfield 8 miles Gina is amazing! What a great experience. It was such a special day and you can tell ...
Lampone Jewelers Inc Lampone Jewelers Inc 8 miles My whole family has been going to them for years. They are wonderful people and do ev...
Schwanke-Kasten Jewelers Schwanke-Kasten Jewelers 8 miles We have been Schwanke-Kasten customers for the last 10 years and have enjoyed friendl...
Shaw's Jewelers Shaw's Jewelers 8 miles What a bs place and their sh$@t employees. I call to ask for a pair of rings I order ...
Rogers & Hollands Jewelers Rogers & Hollands Jewelers 8 miles A very pleasant and well versed salesperson named Danuta took care of me during this ...
Kesslers Diamonds - Germantown Kesslers Diamonds - Germantown 10 miles I was serviced quickly and cheerfully even though I didn't have an appointment set up...
Reviews
We ordered the additional band to my wedding ring because we were told that it was going to be discontinued and that it was available in my exact size. We weren't crazy about $900 price tag on it, but we were told with coupons they had on file for us and with it going on clearance that it was dropped to $600. However, when we picked it up they tried charging us the $900 and tried saying that our coupons are now expired. Why would you tell us prior that we could use them? We were going to send the ring back, but they gave us somewhat of a lower price, nowhere near the $600 they originally told us, but we had to waive the warranty on it. Once I tried the ring on I realized it was way too big. I brought it to a jeweler and they said it was a size 7. I'm a size 5.5...We will never shop at this location again. Or even Kay Jewelers in general. The manager there is a liar and cannot be trusted. She was the one we dealt with through all of this. I also had to get the prongs on the ring fixed because they were already coming up, so I could have lost the diamonds out of it. The last thing anyone needs to worry about so close to their wedding day is a jeweler who sells you an incorrectly sized and defective piece of jewelry for a misleading price. Scam.
9 years ago (21-09-2017)
Buying an engagement ring for my girlfriend here was an absolute nightmare. The sales staff are very pushy and do not listen at all. They kept trying to up sale me the whole time suggesting rings that I did not want even after I had made my decision on a ring kept trying to show me the exact opposite of what I was asking for. The sales person even went as far as to say that my girlfriend would not like the ring I picked out and I'm guessing it had to do with the price. They made the both of us feel very uncomfortable and kept pushing to open a credit line. The products were very nice but the sales staff seemed very rude. I would not buy anything from this store in the future and would recommend people avoid this store.
11 years ago (08-11-2015)
Very nice staff, though as some other reviews say, a little pushy.
9 years ago (22-04-2017)
The only reason this place gets a single star is because the end result was a nice enhancer for my engagement ring, but I had to go through H*LL to get it. My engagement ring is from a different store, and the difference in customer service between the two is incredible. From the beginning we were pushed to get open a line of credit with the store, which we said no to. We were charged $229 to size the enhancer up, and while the ring was at the shop being sized we received a call saying they made a mistake and should have charged us double that because "technically it's two separate rings." I of course said no, I'd rather not pay over half the cost of the ring just to size it up (we were charged nothing by Rogers & Hollands to size my engagement ring up) and wanted a refund, at which they said nevermind they would just forget the extra charge and do it anyway. Then we received another call saying there was a delay at the shop and it would take longer to get it back. When I went two weeks later to pick up the enhancer, my engagement ring did not fit inside. The lady looked at me and asked why I didn't send my ER out with the enhancer?? I said, well, because YOU never told me I would need to! So they "rushed" my ring out with the enhancer and said this time it would only take 8 days to get it back. I told them I was nervous just handing them my engagement ring and she looked at me like I was crazy. 6 days into that, I received a call saying that I had to approve the way my ring sits into my enhancer, so they texted me a picture and I told them yes, that it looked fine and to send it back. The manager said they would call if it wasn't going to be in that weekend. I went two days AFTER they said it would be in, and the girl told me it wasn't there and that it was my fault because I never called them back to ok the picture. I told her I had spoken with the manager and she was supposed to tell the shop to send it back, but she apparently forgot to do so! So I had to wait an extra FIVE DAYS for them to "rush" my ring back to me. At this point the girl tells me, by the way, we have a $340 BALANCE on our account. I told her that is ridiculous, I had already spoken to someone about the $229 and was told we would not be charged it, and that I had no idea where the extra $110 was coming from?! She tried to call me out on lying, then said she would "talk to someone about it," so I called Kay's customer support to sort it all out. They ended up not charging me the extra, but I was miffed that they were trying to put ridiculous extra charges on me. I went today to pick my enhancer up after it was FINALLY back in, got home and realized a ruby had fallen out of my engagement ring! I called Kay's and it took 5 calls for them to pick up the phone. Then the girl tells me it was MY FAULT because it must have fallen out on my way home from their store, since I didn't notice it missing while I was there. Luckily I know Rogers & Hollands will fix my engagement ring ASAP no problem, but seriously?! I have worn this ring for a year and NEVER had a stone fall out!!! The bottom line is the communication within this store SUCKS and DO NOT EVER give them your own jewelry because they will tamper with it and blame it on you. I want to return the enhancer altogether but I don't have time before our wedding to have a new one made. I should have stuck with Rogers & Hollands from the beginning, they treat me well there. I would never have expected to go through such a hassle with our wedding bands. Stay far away from this store at all costs.
12 years ago (02-10-2014)
Poor service
11 years ago (19-03-2016)
Comment on this business

Kay Jewelers map

to add Kay Jewelers map to your website;



Find nearby businesses, restaurants and hotels

Copyright 2025 | All rights reserved (v2)

Terms Of Service
Privacy Policy
Business Listing Service Agreement
0.0057 Loaded in seconds

We use cookies

We use cookies and other tracking technologies to improve your browsing experience on our website, to show you personalized content and targeted ads, to analyze our website traffic, and to understand where our visitors are coming from. Privacy Policy